Report from California: Rallying Against H8
I knew this rally would be different when I heard the disco music from a couple of blocks away. It wasn’t that people weren’t angry or saddened or generally disillusioned about the State Supreme Court’s decision – we were – but it felt like the whole crowd knew that even though we lost this battle, we have a really good shot at winning the war.
And on that note, I would like to take a moment to offer my thanks to NOM and the Yes on 8 Campaign. Your dedicated efforts have galvanized the LGBT community and its many straight friends and supporters, and your complete asshattery has shown many people who were on the fence about gay marriage just how backwards and mean-spirited your position really is.Thanks for teaching a whole new generation that bigotry isn’t cool.
Which is not to say that the Prop 8 ruling shouldn’t scare the bejeezus out of everyone. The court has essentially said that, fair or not, under the California Constitution a majority of voters can take basic rights away from any minority they care to single out.
And while that opens up some amazing pranking territory – Nobody tell the redheads we’re taking away their right to sleep next year, OK? – it also opens up the possibility for HippieProgressiveDoWhatYouFeelLand to slide right into the Dark Ages.
OK, fine: I will sign on to take away the voting rights anyone who puts “Escape (The Piña Colada Song)” into the music mix of any restaurant, bar, or public place, but that’s IT.
But that’s all part of the road ahead. Tuesday night was about showing that we will not take the revocation of rights quietly, and we will not back down.
We gathered at Santa Monica and San Vincente at 7 p.m.. The police on the ground were already well prepared, and choppers were already circling. March organizers circulated through the crowd taking donations and passing out signs, and the gathering protesters – myself included – went into a flurry of compulsive documentation.
We took pictures, we made phone calls, we texted and Twittered. What did people do at protest starts before cell phones and online social media? Make meaningful human connections and fall in love? Well, hell, it was a marriage rally – many of the people there had already taken care of that. (Though one enterprising gentleman had a sign with the coda “P. S. – I’m husband hunting!”)
The signs, as always, were terrific. I’d tossed my hand-made sign from the November rally downtown and didn’t set aside the required 37 hours to make a new one, so I self-consciously went with an old-but-cherished “Vote No on 8” sign.
I needn’t have worried – in many ways the rally was an eco-friendly Prop 8 Protest Greatest Hits collection. I saw signs I recognized from the protest at the Mormon Temple and the march downtown… One couple even had candles from the candlelight vigil.
Among the new signs, Bill from the “I’m Just a Bill” Schoolhouse Rock episode was a definite trend, though he was cast very differently in every sign I saw. One showed him crying, another showed him with devil horns and a Prop 8 badge. And one I’ll just call disturbing and leave it at that. I may need to have those brain cells removed.
An astonishing number of people showed up to speak at the rally, including the mayors of Los Angeles and West Hollywood, several members of the clergy, and Jennifer Pizer of Lambda Legal, who announced the Marriage Watch: California project.
There was also a microphone that was something of a drama queen, cutting out just as people hit the highs of their speeches. The crowd was good-natured about it, chuckling and applauding the return of sound rather than assuming evil machinations of The Man.
Speaking of The Man, incumbent Democrats who haven’t yet had best review footage of the speeches – one of the biggest cheers of the evening was for divorcing the Democratic party if they don’t begin to follow through on years of promises.
Lieutenant Daniel Choi was on hand and drew huge applause – not just for his bravery on several fronts, but because he has already become a powerful and inspiring speaker. Choi also marched the route with the crowd, mingling and shaking hands at times, but also just marching and chanting like everyone else.
He took the stage with “My name is Dan Choi, and I am still gay!” and started the best chant of the evening: “Love is worth it!”
George Takei and his magnificent voice energized the rally with his funny and romantic proposal story, and Kathy Griffin sent the crowd off marching on a wave of good cheer by, well, being Kathy Griffin.
And, at last, the marching. After a burst of simultaneous texting as everyone tried one last time to find the friends we had thought it would be so easy to meet up with, we set off down Santa Monica Boulevard at a good pace.
I am, in an odd way, proud to report that my personal streak of always having someone directly behind my left ear who is determined to lead the chants through sheer volume and force of will remains unbroken.
We marched through West Hollywood, distinctly friendly territory. People darted in and out of the flow of protesters, saying hi or gently teasing each other for watching instead of marching.
Other neighborhoods offered more bemused spectators – particularly the firemen who found themselves the objects of some enthusiastic attention – but overall the march was uneventful.
It was an odd march, more of a placeholder or a promise than anything else. 14,000 people showing up just to make the point that we’re paying attention and this isn’t over.
Hitting the streets is the fun part; now it’s time for the less sexy but equally important slog: collecting signatures, canvassing, and data entry. Leaning on our elected officials and not letting them get away with weaseling. Noodging friends into coming along for that phone banking shift and writing courteous but pointed letters to public figures who need to be reminded that you don’t get to be a dickweed without consequences.
It may be a long push, and sometimes the road to equality will be filled with tedious, difficult, or even scary work.
But last time I checked, love is worth it.





As it’s been said, a key factor in the passage of Prop 8 was the large influx of African-American voters who are one of the demographics most strongly opposed to homosexuality, but conversely have one of the lowest voter-turnouts. Without another major candidate to draw them to the polls, Prop 8 supporters will lose a significant chunk of their voters while those who want it remain consistent.
#
Steven Manning Said: May 27th, 2009 at 6:33 pm
*
I’m so glad I got out of the gay lifestyle and the heterophobes. It’s like 5 tons of weight off my shoulders. My common sense came back to me. I’m so happy. No matter which way winds of society blows. I’ll never go back…NEVER! I”m free of it! Free of it! The gay lifestyle is a bunch of shackles that keeps the real you in a dungeon….a very dark one.
Perhaps you will be one of the few who makes it the rest of your life without a relapse. Perhaps you can be successful spending your life “fighting” who you are. Use extreme caution so that the “real you” doesn’t escape and confront you when you least expect it. It can be a real bitch when the real you rears its ugly head after you have convinced family and friends that you are “reformed sinner” and it turns out that you are just another “queer” that fell for a bunch of religious crap.
It’s over, folks. The bad guys won. The hicks & the haters discovered that they can vote people’s human dignity away at the ballot box.
Prophesy: within 5 years they will w/ respect to legal status, vote us back to the 1950s…
I see us breaking down the arguments against it. With people like Eugene Robinson arguing for us, we will win.
I respect the passion that almost everyone in California has. It is so encouraging to see people stand up for what they believe. I live in Florida and wish that just “some” people in South Florida (a heavy GLBT population area) would do the same. I look forward to the day that I can stand proud with my brothers and sisters in California and fight for what is right.
Yes, it is a scary world in which freedoms can be taken away from any singled-out group. How quick we forget that it could happen to others as well. Let’s say that ONLY Jews can own property in California; or Mormons can ONLY own houses in certain zip codes. Pick anything ridiculous and if freedoms are up for grabs, these could happen. I would never wish those two scenarios upon anyone, but the fact that it could happen is quite chilling.
Best of luck my friends and I will remain a contributor to EQCA. (And yes, I am Happy to give my full name.)
I’m so glad I got out of the gay lifestyle and the heterophobes. It’s like 5 tons of weight off my shoulders. My common sense came back to me. I’m so happy. No matter which way winds of society blows. I’ll never go back…NEVER! I”m free of it! Free of it! The gay lifestyle is a bunch of shackles that keeps the real you in a dungeon….a very dark one.
I was reading Ali Davis’ article today and ran across a word I’ve never heard before: Asshattery. So I stopped to look it up in an on-line dictionary. I tried 3 different dictionaries and couldn’t find it. So I googled it and the Urban Dictionary came up with the definition and pictures. The definition makes perfect sense.
1. asshattery – Acts committed by an asshat or asshats. 2. Engagement in an activity normally reserved for asshats.
I demand that all of you stop this asshattery at once!
1. asshat – One who has their head up their ass. Thus wearing their ass as a hat.
Thanks for the new word and “Thanks for teaching a whole new generation that bigotry isn’t cool.”
whats up my lgbt broher sand sisters , just remebr we gotta stick together andnt fear , the constitution still entitles ud the right to fre speach , dont hide behind half your name , show them they cant scare us , join me in putting your full name and location , when you speak out , i do and i hope the rest of you will join me , its all part of winning and fighting against our enemies with pride , and no church leade or public official can take that from us , united we stand kid , stand for something of fall for anything , dont let these homophobes win.PLEASE TYPE YOUR NAME AND LOCATION WITH NO FEAR ! they count on that fear and silence remeber that …….
What Nick said.
Another ballot initiative is not the way to go in California. If, after spending millions of dollars, the voters rule in our favor, will that be the end of it? No. So long as ballot initiatives can give or take away civil rights by a simple majority vote in California, it’s a never ending process. The bigots will then have their own ballot initiative, and so on and so on. No. This has to be settled by the Supreme Court, one way or another.
Don’t look to the Democrats for help. Who was it who signed the federal DOMA, not to mention DADT? Oh yeah, Bill Clinton. Who hasn’t said peep about Prop. 8 and refuses to end DADT? Oh yeah, Obama.
God and the Constitution are on our side. We were created, (or evolved) so our sexuality is our birthright. (not a choice) We are protected by a Constitution and it’s bill of inalienable rights. Marriage equality needs to drive these two points home. We are natural, normal, equal and demand recognition and respect. Our time is now and we will fight for it with inexaustable pride. Prop 8 and the relilgious right has done us a favor.
Ok fine. I’ll tell ya what folks, you signature gatherers go and do your little repeal thing and waste another 40-50 million bucks on an initiative that WILL NOT WORK. I for one won’t be donating a single dime towards it. What I will be doing is what I have been doing since november of last year: Boycotting California goods and services! Boycotts work folks. Peace out.
We may have lost the battle, but we will win the war. At least the 18,000+ couples got to keep their marriages. That is a small win! We need to look at the positives here and we need to try and stay positive. It is the only thing that will overcome all this hate we are facing every single day of our lives. California Prop 22, in 2000, passed with a 62% majority. In 2008, Prop 8 passed with only a 52% majority. We have gained 10% of the population’s support for our cause in just 8 years! That really is incredible. Theoretically, we could easily gain marriage equality by 2012. We are gaining ground, and we can never stop. Don’t give up on Prop 8! We must continue to fight this! Our enemies may be larger and stronger, and this fight unfair, but we are quicker and are finding things they’ve never had before. I know there are a lot of emotions going on, and I too was very upset about hearing about Prop 8 being upheld, but we musn’t give up. If we show hate we are only falling into our enemie’s trap. That is exactly what they want. They want us to get mad, they want to discourage us. We cannot and will not show them that! If they push us down 1,000 times, we must stand up 1,0001!
The prop. 8 ruling should strike fear in the hearts of all Californians. Everybody is a minority..somehow