Report from San Francisco: Protesting Prop 8
I live in San Francisco just west of Twin Peaks, the hills that hold back the ocean fog and guarantee a remarkably un-San Franciscan number of sunny days in the gay part of town to the east.
It’s more conservative than many other parts of the city; not Dan White territory, certainly, but it has its moments. I grew up there, went to Catholic school there, and came out there.And Friday, when I got on the streetcar to go to the Prop 8 protest at the Civic Center, I had to stand all the way downtown, because what looked like every student at San Francisco State was on their way to the protest, too.
I’m sure some of them were queer ā my gaydar pinged a few times. But there were lots of boy-girl couples, young people of every ethnicity, computer geeks and pierced-eyebrow performance arts majors, straight boys clinging to their girlfriends’ hands, giggling young people texting back and forth with friends at the other end of the train, girls in rhinestone-studded flip-flops debating earnestly if they should get off at the Church St. or Van Ness stations to pick up the march.
When I got downtown, it was much the same, only on a much larger scale. The age range had increased, from babies in their parents arms to veterans of the ACT-UP days of the ’80s, from those of us who remember Harvey Milk and watched police cars burning at City Hall, to those earnest young people hungry for their defining moment of protest in the cause of equal rights for all of us.
Maybe I should have expected it. I’d experienced something like it on election day, standing on a street corner with a group of “No on 8″ volunteers holding campaign signs, getting thumbs up and honked horns and cheers of support from grizzled old Chinese men and hip young black teenaged boys, soccer moms and ten-year-olds, bus and truck drivers, elderly women walking their dogs. But the crushing loss of the day after had wiped out that high, and I’d forgotten.
“Gay, straight, black, white: marriage is a civil right,” they chanted. The hundreds of people trapped in rush hour traffic while we streamed by opened their windows and pounded the sides of their cars, whooping in support. People stood in open sunroofs and climbed onto the hoods of their cars, waving signs they’d written on pieces of paper: “Stop the Hate ā Repeal Prop 8.”
There were no arrests, and the entire counter-protest consisted of two guys with “Protect Marriage” signs that I read about in the morning paper. No one I know even saw them. And despite the complaints of imminent bloodthirsty persecution from a vengeance-fearing religious right, the only threat I heard didn’t involve any form of violence or destruction.
“We’re liberals, sweetie,” said one man marching next to me. “We’re not going to burn their churches. We’re just going to tax ‘em.” He waved to a group of people on the sidewalk, with hand-lettered signs saying “Tax the church,” a chant lustily taken up by the passing marchers.
The march had begun at the Civic Center, near the steps of City Hall that had gone up in flames and violence in the aftermath of Dan White’s manslaughter conviction for the assassination of Harvey Milk and Mayor George Moscone in 1978. It had poured down Market St., the main east-west artery of the city, and tied up with traffic and public transit at the busiest time of day. As we turned into the Castro, though, things slowed down, the narrower neighborhood streets forcing us to crush closer together.
The streets now were lined not with restaurants and office buildings but homes, and in many of their windows were whole families, kids included, waving “No on 8″ campaign signs, and cheering. Two men pulled a wagon with two children, wrapped in a blanket, down the sidewalk, and one little girl stood on her porch, “No on 8″ stickers pasted to each cheek, her smiling moms next to her.
I stopped at the drugstore at the corner of 18th and Castro to buy a new memory card for my camera, since I’d left my spare one at home. The guy who helped me was around my age, and he nodded out the door to the noisy, endless crowd in the street. “Those aren’t all gay people, are they?”
I shook my head. “They’re really not. Kind of amazing. And nice.”
He smiled, and it was radiant. “It never used to be that way.”
“No,” I said. “It never did.”
I don’t know what will happen to Prop 8 as it faces challenges in the courts. I don’t know what’s inside the hearts and minds of those who think this is fair or just, or those who think somehow our families are a threat to theirs. I don’t know what will happen in all the other states with these mean-spirited amendments, or what exact path we’ll have to follow to win our equality under the law.
But I do know that we’re very far from alone in this fight, and that we have one ally that our opponents don’t: we have the young people of this country, and that means we have the future.





i live in a rather notorious little town behind the orange curtain called laguna beach. this past saturday evening i experienced something here that i thought i would never see. upwards of 2000 people marching and chanting in support of gay marriage. as i was walking after the march a str8 man with tears in his eyes,who i have seen around town but never actually met, came up to me and expressed how happy he was for me at the show of support of my community. the crowd was a nice mix of parents with their children and gays and lesbians. i was proud of my laguna beach twice in one week!
THank you! THis is a great description of that evening – and it is in stark contrast to the “gays v. blacks” headlines we’ve been reading in the LA Times!
I just thought of something.
The Mormons were aggressive in their support of Prop 8. They donated huge amounts of money. They sent their believers out to CA to fight to Prop 8. And they made commercials.
My question is this: Has anybody checked to see if these UTAH Mormons registered to vote in CA. I mean, Utah is a foregone conclusion for the Presidency and other conservative issues. Could it be possible that these Mormons registered to vote in CA to affect the measure? And how could we tell?
I loved this story! “…we have the young people of this country, and that means we have the future.” I couldn’t have said that better myself.
Frankly said: “Has anybody checked to see if these UTAH Mormons registered to vote in CA.”
You might be onto something. I can’t recall the source at this moment, but I did read somewhere that Mormons were planning to register in CA in order to vote for Prop 8. Whether they actually did or not, I don’t know. If I find the source, I’ll post it here at the site.
Truly inspiring piece of writing, truly inspiring act of kindness. I only wish I didn’t live in the potent little town so that I could be there.
Has anyone asked who runs the no on 8 campaign, and why the campaign sucked so bad? Let’s be honest we all felt like it was pretty crappy – not a single gay person on tv? always reacting to the rightwing attacks and never going on the offense? a bad ground game? the list goes on. Let’s get new leadership.
A wonderful piece about the City I love. I came out from Chicago 35 years ago, hoping that I would find some semblance of tolerance. I found more than tolerance. I found full acceptance. My first lovers’ parents treated me as a welcomed and beloved son-in-law.
When the AIDS epidemic hit, I was PRIVILEGED to volunteer at the AIDS Emergency Fund. It was an epiphany of sorts: thousands of people, straight and gay, were doing so much for strangers (both straight and gay), not because it was “The Christian Thing To Do” but because it was the HUMAN thing to do.
Although other metropolitan areas followed suit (some, lamentably, much later), it was San Francisco that met the disease head on and took the lead in compassion – and held it. To the Christofascists who demeaned themselves by coming up with Proposition 8, I would point to that era and show them that true Christianity was not to be seen anywhere. San Francisco was, to many, the lone Samaritan in our supposedly “Christian Nation.”
Now here is a question I’d like to throw out to everyone out there in the blogosphere: the oh-so-Christian ProtectMarriage.com performed an act of criminal extortion on the donors of Equality California. WHY HAVEN’T THEY BEEN CHARGED WITH EXTORTION? Their letter to the donors was clear: “pay up or else!” To date, neither the ACLU nor Lambda Legal have gotten back to me with anything about this crime. And what strings did ProtectMarriage have to pull to avoid being charged?
Just a nagging thought.
Thanks again, Christie. You and SF offer a glimmer of hope.