July 4th, 2009
 

365 Gay: Opinion

Besen: The raw energy of post-Prop 8

, columnist, 365gay.com

Few people at the three Proposition 8 protest rallies I attended — two in New York and one in Chicago — were familiar.

The ones I recognized were the hardcore advocates and tireless workhorses who have long carried the GLBT movement.

However, these semi-spontaneous rallies had a different flavor. There was an injection of raw energy and an infusion of new inspiration that has eluded our movement for more than a decade. I peered into the great expanse and saw a wide-eyed sea of fresh new faces — neophytes who needed help to complete the old chant, Hey, hey, Ho Ho…(Homophobia’s got to go).

There has been a paradigm shift in the movement following marriage defeats in California, Florida and Arizona — as well as an anti-gay adoption measure passing in Arkansas. From seemingly out of nowhere, people who have sat on the sidelines are now making headlines at rallies across America.

The leaders of what is being billed as Stonewall 2.0 are not coming from large, established organizations, but Internet savvy activists who can use a mouse to mobilize the masses. While Internet activism is nothing new, the fact that this huge outpouring of organic outrage is not being channeled through official organizational channels has enormous implications.

Up until two weeks ago, major GLBT groups instructed people to write a check and then essentially instructed donors to check their activism at the door. Sometimes, one was asked to take their commitment a step further by sending e-mail or attending a dinner. I think this week’s protests mark the end of the Passive Era of gay politics. A sign at protests, “No More Mr. Nice Gay”, highlighted this monumental change.

Now, don’t get me wrong, the Passive Era served its purpose. By the mid 1990’s exhaustion had beset the movement. Many leading activists had either died from AIDS or were worn out from fighting the culture wars. People felt deflated by the early Clinton years and dispirited after Newt Gingrich wrested control of Congress. Most of the tangible results during this period occurred in the courts, which produced historic victories, but relegated most GLBT people to cheering bystanders.

At this moment of malaise, technology afforded people the ability to engage in activism without leaving the house. While these notable advances have greatly aided the GLBT movement, they also allowed many people to be anesthetized by the Internet. It soon became a movement of elite movers and shakers, with little room for direct action.

The upside to the Passive Era was that aspiring gay insiders actually did sometimes get inside the halls of power and have a voice in the political process. Our organizations became more professional, better organized and institutionalized, which meant that they were not always on the brink of bankruptcy and had the ability to plan for the future.

But, make no mistake - we are not the same movement we were prior to Nov. 4. Having our marriage rights stripped away by a slim majority in California was a transformational experience for many gay, lesbian, bisexual and transgender individuals. I have lost count of those who have approached me to say that they never thought they were the political type — until now. These people will bring new ideas, untapped energy and significantly strengthen our work.

It is still unclear how this influx of fiery emotion will specifically change the movement. But, I will make the bold prediction that those organizations that do not adjust to this new reality will wither and die. Newer, sleeker models will replace those that remain stodgy and continue to fight by fax, without incorporating the heat on the street. The new activism is a hybrid of direct action and digital activism. It is evolving, mutating and morphing by the day. And, whichever groups figure out how to be a conduit for this anger — and effectively turn it into a force — will lead the movement in the coming years.

This is a rare moment where the pain of Proposition 8 meets the possibility represented by Barack Obama. A great many people can now see that passion can lead to real progress — and they demand a role in creating change.

Lastly, the rules of the Mormon, Catholic and Evangelical churches are now enshrined into civil law. We are all unofficial members of these religious institutions and captive to their narrow, sectarian rules. They have effectively hijacked the state and now govern our personal relationships and private lives — whether we like it or not. I think people are finally awakened to this existential threat and willing to fight back.

On Nov. 8, I stood in freezing weather with hundreds of Chicagoans. Last week in Washington, 900 protesters braved a tornado watch to rally in front of the Capitol. Far from a victory, anti-gay forces unleashed a ferocious storm with powerful winds of change that will only end with the sound of wedding bells.


Comments (8)
  • Wayne Said: November 19th, 2008 at 4:29 pm
    • It really was nice to see so many within the younger generation stepping into the role of activist.

  • barb Said: November 19th, 2008 at 4:31 pm
    • I completely agree; they have energized our movement in ways we could only have hoped for! To see a nationwide, even worldwide response to the California Yes on 8 vote is truly amazing and encouraging. We couldn’t have asked for people to take this kind of action; they have to want it from their hearts and minds. We won’t be content with just “pride parades” anymore; we’re taking to the streets until we have true equality! Here’s hoping that the California Supreme Court puts an end to discrimination immediately with their decision re Prop 8’s constitutionality. We won’t just “get over it” as much as the “yes on 8″ folks might like; we’re just getting warmed up!

  • Jen Marcus Said: November 19th, 2008 at 6:05 pm
    • Yes, its time to take our message for our equality and civil rights to the streets of America! Being silently passive aggressive will not win or secure our rights. For starters, I propose that we boycott and refuse to support finically, and otherwise, any and all of the corporations, religious, secular, political, social institutions and organizations and individuals that aided and abetted in the passage of these discriminatory laws, practices and amendments. All this in conjunction with timed and synchronized strikes and marches coupled with flooding news editorial pages, E-blogs, and letters to politicos all over this nation demanding our civil rights. We must be Heard , Accepted, Recognized, Respected and Reckoned with ! Enough is Enough: this is our Declaration of Independence from the tyranny of the majority!

  • Pati Said: November 19th, 2008 at 8:00 pm
    • I am one of the new faces you talk about. I joined you at the Dobson protest in Chicago (one of the two lesbians that were there early from 30 miles outside the city that recognized you from your picture on this site). I joined the massive crowd a week later on November 15th for the National protest and I am ready to represent again whenever and wherever I am needed. I have a selfish reason for this, I don’t want to leave my state to marry the love of my life when I know it will mean nothing when we come back home to Illinois. This new wave of activism is about much more than the recent anti gay legislation that was passed 2 weeks ago. This is about fighting for our rights and demanding them for gay people all over this country. We can no longer accept second class status. I am out and I am proud and that’s how we all need to be. They can keep their shame and guilt. We have had enough of it!!!!!!!!!

  • LOrion Said: November 19th, 2008 at 8:22 pm
    • Good opening piece, for more: read Kate Kendalls post mortem: nytimes.com/2008/11/20/us/politics/20transition.html?hp
      Where she compares post Nov 4 with Kubler-Rosses 5 STAGES of Grief, (having herself lost 3 family members last year.)
      Kate Calles ours SHOCK, ANGER, BLAME, ACTION, RESOLVE.
      “If there was ever any doubt that we are a movement, that has been put to rest. If there was ever any suspicion that we are too complacent to organize and show our outrage and our resolve, that suspicion has been obliterated. This has been a very dark time…it is becoming clear to me as I pull myself out of the pall that this community is not about to remain silent, we are not going to slip back, we are not going back into any closet, anywhere. We are resolved to never take our equality, anywhere, for granted.
      With all due respect to Kubler-Ross, there will never be acceptance.
       
      I appreciate being included in your fight.
      STR8 Against H8

  • Arthur Said: November 20th, 2008 at 6:15 am
    • While the gay political class attended DC and nationwide cocktail parties to raise money, and put their names in contention for government jobs, they forgot their mission.

      GLBT rights. It’s The Constitution, stupid. Not who you know.

      It is time to exact resignations from our faux power elite. They have failed to organize a grass roots effort, despite their membership in the Democratic Party. They have failed to educate the general populace in the difference between a civil marriage and a religious marriage. They have failed to make us full citizens.

      The notion HRC has been waiting for the right time is nonsense. They wait while thye fail us.

  • DeGuyz Said: November 20th, 2008 at 9:47 am
    • It will be a happy day when the warrior’s no longer have to put their lives in harms way against these morons. I still feel that the undisclosed sector on this movement will one day cast their votes on all of our behalfs in their own private way and help in bringing this endless debate to a equal resolve for all.

  • William Aley Said: November 20th, 2008 at 4:51 pm
    • After years of phone calls asking to just open my wallet and give, most necessary in the not so dim past of obscurity, or attending an expensive dinner designed for motivate to donate, and after a long period of what seems like the just give more era. It was refreshing to walk in the ominous dark clouds bearing down on DC, to be amongst home made signs and grass root energy and rain soaked determination. There is a demand to be included. I was heartened to be amongst the young, who are seeking an opportunity for their relationships to be recognized, for a chance to live in an open civil society and be acknowledged as participants.