Besen: Setting the stage for tragedy
On Sunday, The New York Times featured a chilling article on how fundamentalist Christians stalked, harassed and ultimately murdered Wichita abortion provider George Tiller, who they taunted with the nickname, “Tiller the Baby Killer.”
A lone gunman, who used the e-mail name “ServantofMessiah”, shot Tiller while he ushered at Reformation Lutheran Church, where he and his wife were active members. Prior to Tiller’s assassination, the “loving” faithful had put bullets in his arms and bombed his clinic.Unfortunately, with Tiller’s controversial clinic finally out of business, the lesson for the loony may be that lethal force is more effective than lobbying. In the Times article, Mark Geitzen, chairman of the Kansas Coalition for Life, expressed this sentiment when he said during a phone conversation, “God has his own way…but you can’t say our prayers weren’t answered.”
Tiller’s death vividly illustrates the danger posed by the violent language and imagery used by fanatics, who believe they are personally entrusted to enforce God’s will. What concerns me is that the aggressive tactics used against abortion providers are slowly seeping into the anti-gay movement.
As the wider culture becomes more accepting, homophobes are growing increasingly frustrated, which has led to bolder and more confrontational actions. Are anti-gay leaders egging on unstable followers to attack gay people or provoking gays to defend themselves so they can manufacture martyrdom and justify retaliation?
At the Dore Alley Fair in San Francisco last weekend, a number of muscular Christians wearing Jesus shirts reportedly tried to march through the event thumping Bibles and waving signs.
In Charlotte, Dr. Michael Brown, the founder of the Coalition of Conscience, organized several hundred followers in red shirts to descend like uninvited locusts on Charlotte Pride last week under the banner, “God Has a Better Way.”
Aside from the pompous name of their demonstration, the protesters confronted gay people and browbeat them with cherry picked Bible verses. Brown’s ostensible reason for marshaling the troops was to introduce Pride attendees to his angry version of God.
But, of course, the notion that gay people in conservative North Carolina needed Brown to educate them about religious fundamentalism was farcical. Indeed, many of the people at Pride had only found personal acceptance after long journeys to reconcile their spirituality and sexuality.
No, Brown was really there to besiege Charlotte’s gay residents with his hostile hordes. His group’s in-your-face presence was designed to disrupt peaceful assembly and make Pride attendees feel guilty and uncomfortable so that they might skip future gay events.
Fortunately, the pious proselytizers were on their best behavior after the militant writings and actions of Brown came under intense scrutiny by local Q-Notes editor Matt Comer. In his research, Comer found that Brown started his FIRE School of Ministry to “raise up a holy army of uncompromising spirit-filled radicals who will shake an entire generation with the gospel of Jesus by life or death.”
In a vacuum, such religious language may be viewed as a relatively benign rhetorical flourish. However, when followers are portrayed as holy warriors in a life and death struggle against a minority group that is falsely accused of working to undermine freedom of religion, the seeds of potential disaster are intentionally being sown.
In advertising his rally, Brown proclaimed that the “hour is urgent” and that Christians must “turn back the tide of homosexual activism.” In a written statement following his intolerance invasion of Pride, Brown wrote, “Enough is enough to the destructive goals of gay activism…we say it stops in Charlotte.”
Most alarming are these charlatans’ deliberate perpetuation of paranoia by trumpeting alleged religious persecution that exists only in their warped minds. For example, in his statement Brown accused gay people of “trying to put Christians in the closet.” And, he capped it off by saying that gay people are “tampering with the foundations of human society.”
Brown tries to cover his tracks by sprinkling his apocalyptic rhetoric with calls for non-violence. Good orators, however, understand the principle of “layering” messages. If in one sentence you speak of violence and in the next of non-violence, the listener will almost always embrace the words that support his or her belief system.
Dr. Brown isn’t naïve and surely understands that the GLBT masses will not retreat into the closet unless events conspire to make coming out a blood sport. Short of extreme bullying and brutality he’ll never accomplish his lost cause of “stopping” progress on gay rights in Charlotte.
Brown, of course, doesn’t actually have to make an overt pitch for mayhem. Simply by inciting his flock he is setting the stage for future tragedy. It is time for Brown and his comrades to abort their increasingly hostile and combative tactics before it leads to more wanton death in the name of abundant life.





It is time to make those who incite to riot and murder guilty as if it was their hand.
Hitler didn’t murder any Jews, or anyone else as far as I know. And he was a Catholic who often talked about Providence.
Unfortunately we didn’t get to hang him slowly.
Most of history’s tyrants have either been religious or supported in one way or another by relgion.
And who knows – perhaps 500 million have been murdered by their words.
Time to make the churches who use hatred in the name of God responsible for their speach.
Just as we did with a lot of Hitlers stooges.
We cannot just sit back and let the religious right spew out their lies and deceptions without confronting them. LGBT people, especially those of us who are Christian must send letters, e-mails and other communications that politely, but firmly hold them accountable for their lies. Their lies cost people their lives.
They say they are exercising free speech and freedom of religion. They must be told that free speech comes with responsibilities to avoid libel and character assassination or use of speech to raise fear or hate. Freedom of religion does not include the abuse of religion to excuse hate-mongering or a right to misinterpret the Bible to justify hate.
When incidents happen where there are violent attacks on women’s clinics or LGBT clubs and gathering spaces, we must not let the so-called “pro-life” or “pro-family” movements get away with phony statements about how they oppose such violence. They need to be told, bluntly, that their statements and their lies encourage those acts of violence and that they have blood on their hands.
And by the way, when we write these organizations, even if they ignore us, there is always the possibility our letters could give hope to a person working in those organizations who is trying to hide from his sexual orientation or gender identity– and give them the courage they need to come out of the closet.
The scary thing about this scenario is that we even have to worry about it, but we do. I guess the question I have this this: As more and more breeders begin to feel less and less threatened by queers, will these so-called Christians fade into the background like skinheads or the KKK? Having attended Pride in Tuscaloosa, AL and Birmingham, I know that there are decent folks out there that wouldn’t stand with Brown, but would they speak out against him? Hmmm…
I don’t know what to say about this any more… every day there’s more and more hateful Christian propaganda and rhetoric. What can we really do? UNFORTUNATELY they have the same rights as we do. I support atheist groups that want to take away their tax exempt status; maybe when that goes, so will the Christian Rite.
I, for one, cannot understand how one can be gay and Christian. But, that notwithstanding, it’s hard to disagree with the points made by Besen except for one. It’s not a concept to think about for the future. It’s happening right now. Presently we call them hate crimes and almost always, it seems, they are somehow rooted in religious beliefs. This is a serious problem and will take at least a few generations to cycle out of the mainstream once we get the equality we seek.
This may sound paranoid, but if you’ve grown up around these people, you learn to take their talk seriously. Do I think that there are a significant number of fundamentalists who would view attacks on gays as god’s work? Hell yes. These people are indistinguishable from the hardliners in Iran. Although most aren’t as fixated on gays as they are on abortion, don’t rule it out. To me, they have a shared mental illness, a sick group-think. It’s not about belief–they really believe that a supernatural force endorses their anti-social behavior.
Hey Joey:
Go to “American Family Association”: click on “OneNewsNow”.
These people spend more time on gay issues, than does 365!!
(Read it daily for at least 2 weeks). Lies!!
Inkky…those sites are SCARRY!!!
I just went to some CT-oriented site…holy crap. They go on and on about horrible rates and statistics for children living in divirced or single parent households and equate that to the reason to fight for traditional marriage. CRAZY! That is not equal to same-sex marriage…but a non-suspecting reader would think otherwise.
WOW…Im sooo offended!
But…we prevailed (their website is a bit outdated) and now have full marriage equality in CT…so not all is lost.
WOW though. Thanks for sending me looking for that stuff. A real eye opener as to why it is imperative to continue to fight these lies.
Sarrellec Said – Absolutely!
If one thinks that these people can be talked to then they also believe that a wife beater can be talked to and convinced to stop beating his wife. Yeah, right!
We can wish that this confrontation between christian fanatics and anyone they determine is an enemy would or could be solved peacefully and without loss of life and limb.
History teaches us that this is not going to happen. Christianity must have an enemy in order to exist.
Gays are the enemy du jour.
In EVERY instance of fanatical christian opposition to the rights of their enemy to exist, be considered equal, or to live their lives without the interference of the fanatical christian, VIOLENCE has been the consistent answer of the fanatical christian.
If we do not learn from history, we are doomed to repeat it. Unfortunately, what this history teaches us is that there is NO WAY to NOT repeat the fanatically violent actions of christians.
So, we should just come to terms with that reality.
We will lose people. That’s a given.
These violent actions from the fanatical christian will, however, work in our favor, just as their insane fanatical violence has eventually worked in the favor of their enemy du jour of the past.
So folks, be as careful as you can, but refuse to live in fear. Be ready for losses and do your best to respond as non-violently as possible.
This will be difficult.
We must simply realize we are in a war we did not start and in which we do not wish to participate, but those who have designated us their enemy simply cannot be stopped UNTIL AFTER they have consummated their fanatacism.
That’s just the way it is.
I have said more than once on this forum that the so-called “loving Christiand” are being taken over by what can correctly be called THE CHRISTIAN TALIBAN. No only are they following the verbal tactics of the Islamic Taliban, now they are beginning to adapt the physical violence of the Islamic Taliban. But the Kumbaya bunch, jumping up and down and screaming “Praise Jesus” try to tell us, and the “moderate” Muslims insist, “oh no, we are not all like that, we are a loving group of people.” Yeah, well bullshit! If you get a bullet in the butt it matters not where it came from, your still dead. Did anyone see “our loving Christian brothers and sisters” showing support for Pride in Charlotte?? Did anyone see “our loving brothers and sisters in San Franciso showing support for the GLBT event? NO! NO! and NO!.
Dr. Tiller was in his church and what did that accomplish? The religious scumbags still killed him. I will be willing to bet that we are going to see a tragic event on a much bigger scale at some future Pride event and it will be caused by some group of religious scumbags. “Praise Jesus?” Praise Jesus my ass!
We had better pull our head out of our ass or we are going to be in BIG trouble. Dr. Brown and his kind are the true Satans of this world. They stink evil. They have shit for brains so don’t expect to see any thinking from them.
Some of the rhetoric Brown (in his less guarded moments) directs at our community, closely resembles the blood-libel and other accusations used by Hitler–and others–against Jews. To suggest that our movement by its nature threatens “the foundation of human society” can readily be used, in the mind of some fanatic, to justify any sort of violent act.
I, for one, believe that the “Christian” right will not be content, until they have at the very least interned us in concentration camps.
Sound far fetched?
Read “American Family Assoc.”, and “Americans for truth about Homosexuality” websites on a daily basis, as I do; read some of the “comments” left by “Christians”. Scary!!
On the one hand, I’ve always thought that kids taking baseball bats to our heads were extensions of the rhetoric of mainstream politicians and preachers (less so today). On the other hand, I don’t think that their efforts against us compare with their efforts against abortion providers until they begin issuing “standing vigils” outside our offices with the goal to block entrance consistently, putting our leaders on watch lists, overty linking “stopping the gays” to “preventing others from murder/death,” and attempts at assassinating our leaders.
I know that we should keep an eye out for warning signs…clue into things before they get too hot. But I don’t think we’re on a par with how they’ve approached abortion providers…yet.
Another thing we have going for us is that the general public seems fractured in their opinions about abortion, yet their support for gay people polls in consistent across topic (with the exception of marriage equality) and with a HUGE upswing toward our side. To mess with us more aggressively will risk backlash among the mainstream people in a way that their anti-abortion activities have not created a backlash yet.