Besen: Obama’s empty words
A debate is raging on whether to have a national gay March on Washington in October. Most leaders I have spoken with are against the idea, preferring to keep scarce financial and human resources in the states. Others, such as myself, are largely ambivalent. A galvanizing force, however, is giving new life to this idea and his name is Barack Obama.
The President is in serious danger of motivating a huge mass of gay people to stream into Washington for the simple joy of standing in front of the White House and giving him a piece of their minds.
This week, an array of GLBT leaders expressed their dismay with the President by pulling out of a Democratic National Committee fundraiser. The action is in protest of a noxious legal brief submitted by the Department of Justice. It implausibly defended the heinous Defense of Marriage Act (DOMA) by using anti-gay arguments that likely drew a standing ovation from Rev. Pat Robertson.
DOJ’s paper included a comparison of gay relationships to incest and opposed same-sex relationships on the absurd basis that it would cost taxpayers money (Don’t gay people pay taxes?). HRC also sent a pointed letter to Obama highlighting the betrayal felt by the gay, lesbian, bisexual and transgender community.
“I cannot overstate the pain that we feel as human beings and as families when we read an argument, presented in federal court, implying that our own marriages have no more constitutional standing than incestuous ones,” wrote HRC’s President, Joe Solmonese.
The deteriorating situation is exacerbated by confusion about who will push for equality. The Obama administration claims to be awaiting congressional action on a number of issues, including ending employment discrimination, eliminating DOMA and repealing Don’t Ask/Don’t Tell. Meanwhile, Senate majority leader Harry Reid is waiting for Obama to act, as well as the House of Representatives. The GLBT community has become a hot potato that the Democrats do not seem to want to touch.
Aggravating matters was John Berry, the highest-ranking gay official in the administration. In an interview with The Advocate, he said that Obama’s timetable to enact his pro-gay campaign promises is “before the sun sets on this administration.”
So, now we have to wait 4-8 years, while watching him suck up to Rick Warren on Day 1?
For what seemed like forever, Democrats told us that when the big bad Republicans went away, our lives would improve. Well, the Republican nightmare is over, so why do I still feel like I’m in the middle of a political Friday the 13th movie?
The Democrats took our money, our votes and our volunteer hours and now they tell us to wait patiently, like good little gays. As far as I’m concerned, if the donkeys can’t deliver now, they can kiss my ass. The Democrats run the show in Washington and if they will not act like a majority party, then they do not deserve to be one.
This is not about making unreasonable policy demands, but about the Democrats recognizing the daily struggles faced by gay people. A new report by The National Coalition of Anti-Violence Programs said, “violence against lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender (LGBT) people increased 2% from 2007 to 2008, continuing the trend of a 24% total increase in 2007.”
Recently, I read about a lesbian who was barred from visiting her partner in a Fresno hospital, and as a result her partner received the wrong medication. Last week, I was in conservative Western Michigan where I spoke to young people who were nearly driven to suicide as a result of anti-gay attitudes.
We need a president who recognizes these evils and demonstrates the courage and leadership to enact the change he so eloquently promised during his campaign.
If Obama continues down the current path it will come at a steep price. When Bill Clinton settled for Don’t Ask/Don’t Tell, it solidified the growing perception that he was “Slick Willie.” By turning his back on the gay community, Obama will play into the idea, stoked by Hillary Clinton and exploited by John McCain, that he is a man of beautiful, yet empty words.
What Obama fails to understand is that when poetry does not translate into policy, and hope turns hollow, the American people will begin to tune him out.
I’m still undecided about the wisdom of a march on Washington, but I am decidedly fed up with my political “friends” marching all over my dignity and taking my support for granted. If the majority party does not cough up the votes to protect our families, we should close down our generous coffers.




If we can’t get anymore than tokenism from a democrat congress and president I will sit out the next election and give them no more monetary support.
Yesterday I mailed another letter to the White House, the second in two months:
The President
The White House
1600 Pennsylvania Avenue N.W.
Washington, D.C. 20500
Dear Mr. President:
How can it be that the Department of Justice brief that defends the discriminatory Defense of Marriage Act by comparing same-sex marriage to pedophilia and incest has not provoked your angry denunciation and repudiation? Do these vile lies published by your Administration truly reflect your beliefs? Is this an example of your “fierce advocacy” of GLBT Civil Rights?
How can it be that you have not yet moved to repeal DADT, as you promised during your campaign? In as much as it is common knowledge that the military apparatus of those nations which now permit their gay and lesbian citizens to serve openly in their armed forces has suffered no crisis or upheaval adversely affecting either morale or mission effectiveness, there is no legitimately compelling reason for this shameful persecution of U.S. military personnel to continue. Is this an example of your “fierce advocacy” of GLBT Civil Rights?
How can it be that you have not expressed moral outrage over the fact that your fellow Americans may be legally denied employment, lodging and housing because of their sexual orientation? Why do you not chide Congress for its failure to enact ENDA? Is this also an example of your “fierce advocacy” of GLBT Civil Rights?
Can it be that the GLBT community has been betrayed by a “bigot, a moral coward and a liar” as some, quicker than I to lose patience with your equivicating failure forthrightly to defend the American Constitutions’s guarantee of Equality and Justice for All, now characterize you? Is this disparagement justified?
I call upon you, Mr. President, to remember the painful travails of legal discrimination that your own persecuted race suffered here just 40 years ago, to stop dithering over these Civil Rights issues, to do the moral and equitable thing and put an end to this outrageous unfairness that blights America’s promise of Equality and Justice for All.
Yours very truly (for now),
It’s hard for me to believe that anyone is actually shocked by the Administration’s actions. The Democrats and Republicans are both the parties of Big Capital, just with different talking points. The two parties may fall in and out of power periodically, but what has always been in control of this country is a small group of capitalists. In order for the LGBT community, and every other oppressed group, to achieve actual liberation, we, the oppressed and disenfranchised (women, minorities, the LGBT community, the working class, religious minorities) must join together to end the real source of our oppression, Capitalism, and establish a democratic Socialist world. Only through the equality of Socialism will any real progress on our front be possible.
James, I read the ‘Declaration.’ Total nonsense. We have to deal with the corruption foisted upon this country by the Christian Taliban. And waiting any longer is NOT going to allow us to see any substantial change. We need to raise our banners and fight – make our voices heard, loud and clear.
I just unsubscribed from the Obama campaign’s ongoing fundraising list-serve, info@barackobama.com, and told them clearly why. No more $$$ from me until they take LGBT concerns seriously. I urge everyone on their list to do the same.
Patience my ASS! What has “patience” gotten us so far? Jack Shit is what! It’s time to hit them where it hurts – money and votes! We won’t be taken for granted anymore!
James – I would agree with having patience on addressing DOMA, DADT, and hate crimes all at once, politics being what they are. And people – especially Bush holdover appointees – can screw up. But it would have taken very little for a “senior White House official” or Obama himself to disavow the language in the brief as soon as they were aware of it, even if they felt they had to defend the law (though God only knows why.)
pull your funding from the democrats and save it to go march in Oct.
One of our biggest problems is that we don’t have any physically defining outward features that shows our homosexuality (no limp wrist jokes please).
I don’t think people realize how many GLBT people there are in this country. Especially those in smaller communities that we tend to avoid like the plague. We need to show them just how many of us there actually are!
Here’s the White House e-mail contact form:
http://www.whitehouse.gov/contact/
FLOOD them with e-mails protesting the President’s inaction.
Go here
http://www.senate.gov
and
http:///www.house.gov
to write your Senators and Representatives.
Don’t think that the Irreligious Reich (sic) isn’t doing the same … they’ve put out “emergency” bulletins opposing the Matthew Shepard Act because it might infringe on their right to preach hate, and they’re calling for phone calls, e-mails, letters, and FACE-TO-FACE LOBBYING.
We CAN’T sit back and wait for the gay “leadership” to do everything for us.
If you’re reading this, you have a computer; it won’t cost you ONE RED CENT to send those e-mails.
A lot of you have free long-distance plans as well.
CALL; be POLITE;
but C-A-L-L!!!
Isn’t our FREEDOM worth a few MINUTES?
Oddly enough, I just addressed this very issue yesterday. And oddly enough, I took a very logical stance to it….which is something I have not seen very much from the community as a whole. Yes, we have the right to make our voices be heard, but be wary of the words that you are using in that process. http://indeclaration.wordpress.com/2009/06/17/there-is-no-bus-to-crawl-out-from-under/ If you find yourself with some time, go have a quick read. It might surprise you and make you think even harder and more in depth than you were before.
AMEN, BROTHER!!
I agree 100% with this article. Very well written.
Who gives a shit if our leaders are going or not. WE need to go to DC and bring new leadership.
Although marches can be fun (and not much more than that), wouldn’t it make more sense to withhold all contributions to the Democratic Party until DOMA repeal, hate crimes,and ENDA have been signed into law and the Pentagon is at least working on DADT repeal?
This is the very reason not once I voted for Obama. I instinctively knew he was full of blah especially on LGBT issues. I truly wished he proved me wrong. In fairness, I’m sure he’s doing his best for everyone, gays not included.