Besen: Let Sam Adams get back to work
Portland’s openly gay mayor, Sam Adams, correctly decided to remain in office after acknowledging that three years ago he had a brief affair with an eighteen year old man. Calls for his resignation were politically motivated, homophobic and cheap shots dressed in the guise of morality. Sadly, many gay and lesbian leaders got sucked into the sexual hysteria and puritanical pandemonium and called for the mayor’s resignation.
If Adams had exploited an innocent youth or abused his power in office to obtain sex, I would not be defending him. The affair with Beau Breedlove, however, was consensual and Breedlove told the Oregonian newspaper:“I do not see any relationship that I ever had with Sam as me being taken advantage of. I do not feel like I was ever a victim.”
Given this reality, I am having a difficult time understanding exactly why this is a controversy. The hypocrisy, double standard and anti-gay undertones are unmistakable. If a 42-year-old male politician had hooked up with an 18-year-old Hooter’s girl, he would get high fives. If he’s gay, people with pitchforks want to hang him from a high tree. For the conquering straight male, the affair would be a sign of virility. For the gay man, it is the mark of vulgarity.
This all goes back to the despicable stereotype that evil homosexuals recruit children into the so-called “lifestyle.” People have to realize that sacrificing Adams won’t erase this insidious myth from the minds of ignorant people who choose to believe it.
As in most self-righteous inquisitions, the pious finger pointers say it is “not about the sex, it is because Adam’s lied” to the media about the tryst. This is the same disingenuous nonsense that Ken “Porn” Starr and the GOP used to rationalize their attempted coup of Bill Clinton.
In my view, Adams is the victim of an overzealous media asking questions about a relationship that was none of their business. There were only two legitimate questions that should ever have been asked of Adams:
Was Breedlove of legal age?
Did Adams supervise him at work?
We know the answer to the first question (barely legal), and Breedlove was an intern in the state capitol, which had nothing to do with the city council, where Adams had served as a commissioner.
So, why is this a story?
When asked about this affair during his campaign, Adams had every right to mislead reporters. What detractors call lying, was really just personal discretion. What next, are we going to pass sunshine laws that mandate public officials must sign sexual disclosure forms listing all sexual liaisons and post their names on the Internet? Because, that is essentially what people want when they insist Adams had an obligation to discuss his private life with the media.
Like starving vultures, the press is now sensationalizing the issue. For example, ABC News’ website published an Associated Press story headlined, “Gay Teen Sex Scandal Mayor Won’t Resign.” This is misleading and irresponsible journalism that makes Adams appear to be a letch who hangs around middle schools with lollipops.
To be fair, Adams did let down the GLBT community. When asked about the affair during his campaign, he should have either told the truth or said, “none of your business.” Instead, he accused his primary opponent of gay baiting and complained, “This is one of the worst smears you can make against a gay guy. It preys on the homophobic stereotype that gay men cannot be trusted with young people.”
Adams diminished the noble cause for equality when he hid behind it to conceal his relationship. He should have acted with more integrity and not made his personal saga about the larger GLBT community.
Still, Adams did apologize profusely and should be allowed to move on. Human beings are not perfect, especially politicians. Last week, hundreds of citizens rallied in front of City Hall in support of Adams, giving him the strength to fight on.
Finally, I’m not begrudging those who think that it is irresponsible and wrong for Adams to have had sex with someone half his age. Those who believe that Adams does not share their values, have every right to vote him out of office when he is up for reelection. But the notion that Adams should be recalled is nothing short of an ugly witch-hunt.
The political judgment of Sam Adams is certainly questionable. There is no question, however, that his actions do not warrant the harsh judgment of those who demand that he resign. One may not like the mayor’s personal choices, but this so-called “scandal” is nothing more than a fake crime scene in search of a real crime.
Adams is no superman, as many supporters thought he once was, but he is also no scoundrel. It is time people stop taking potshots at the mayor, and let him return to work so he can repair the potholes his constituents elected him to fix.





Irresponsible Journalism by self serving reporters, should be made a crime. Punishable also. Their closets are not so lily white, nor clean. Leave the MAYOR of Oakland alone and keep your nose out of personal business. TEND TO YOUR OWN uncleanliness, before someone finds out your dark hidden secrets.
I’m sorry, but I absolutely disagree. The gay “community” practically called for Mark Foley to be lynched over nearly the same behavior. Could it be we want to let Sam Adams stay in his job because he has a (D) after his name, not an (R)?
Frankly this has nothing to do with his sexuality and everything to do with the fact that he lied. I don’t care if Mr. Adams screws everything that moves, until he lies about it. When are we going to start demanding more responsible behavior from our public servants? When will these shenanigans by people on both sides of the aisle be enough?
We end up with the lesser of two evils every election at every level, and we get what we deserve in our political leadership. We are entrusting these people with our money to serve the good of the greater community. We can and should expect higher standards of behavior regardless of sexual orientation. Mr. Adams should resign now.
I was so infuriated that I mistakenly printed Oakland instead of PORTLAND, Oregon. Please excuse. Thank You.
All throughout history old ass heterosexual white men have paid for younger women in socio-political alliances in the form of a “dowry”. More power to Mayor Adams for having enough stamina to handle an eighteen years old man or woman. At least he had someone of age.
Hang tough Sam, You didn’t break the law but you did show poor judgment. Like Wayne said had he hooked up with a Hooters waitress he would have been called one lucky guy but because he is gay he is being treated like a criminal which he isn’t.
Hang Tough Sam!
So because a bad judgment call was made concerning someone else we should make the same mistake over again. Whatever. Sounds like jealousy to me. Good for Mayor Adams and Mr. Breedlove.
I’m sorry, but I absolutely disagree. The gay “community” practically called for Mark Foley to be lynched over nearly the same behavior.
Foley’s case was a bit different. He was a closeted politician who had sponsored legislation to protect youth. And, as a Congressman, he had direct oversight of these youth. Plus, I beleive Congressional Pages are 16.
Why should having consensual sex with a legal adult be an issue? A brief affair is, at the least, slightly irrelevant to a persons ability to perform a job.
Wayne- thank you so much for this very responsible piece. The hypocrisy of this situation is deplorable- the sex is not. The lying about sex- god- even the gay folk on here are beyond judgmental. Get over it. Our socio-religio-cultural base- which is what sets up this stupid scenario in the first place- is beyond stupid and completely disgusts me.
Since you do not live in Portland, and I do, I suggest you keep your uninformed opinion to yourself! This is not about the relationship he had with the young man, it is about our great city needing a mayor we can trust. Sam Adams broke the trust he had with our city and now he must go! Supporting him JUST BECASUE he is gay is stupid at best! I would rather have an honmest straight person as my mayor than a mayor who seems to only tell the truth when it fits his needs. I say that people like you who are sticking their opinions into MY cities business need to focus on issues of national concern, who MY mayor is is NONE OF YOUR BUSINESS! Sam is a fraud and he has shamed this wonderful cities gay community!
I agree with Kevin, unless any of you are from Portland, then you can keep your opinions to yourself. Who are mayor is would be none of your concers and frankly, we here in Portland don’t need your input or opinions, we never have! We willsort this out by ourselves and I hope we recall Sam in June.
“Since you do not live in Portland, and I “I suggest you keep your uninformed opinion to yourself!”
Wow, how provincial. I can only laugh at the parochial nature of these silly comments, that no one outside Portland can have an opinion.
Sorry, but this is national news and people do not have to live in Portland to be informed. They have invented things called newspapers and the Internet, which allow people to be informed about events outside of a ten mile radius.
Coming forward: standing up for yourself, and your rights, is inline with our laws. This is the time to step-up, not step-down.
Right-on Mr. Besen! I agree. This was such an Non-scandal. And good for you responding to the nay-sayers in the comment section.
So the guy had a sexual relationship with another consenting adult…they both happen to be men and no one was hurt. Disclosure of his sexual partners doesn’t define his Mayoral duties.
I work with Mature Adult Heterosexual men all day. The 18-19 year old women they’ve had relationships with are treated like conquests. And the comments made about the 16-17 y/o female customers would make the media cringe. Am I to think less of their values because they sleep with younger women?
If I mention how a attractive younger male customer may be, they become quite uncomfortable and are quick to change the subject. Should they think less of my values?
Homophobia is not tolerated at my buiness. Yet there still remains a subtle double standard. This double standard even runs among our own GLBT community.
If your more concerned about two consenting adults and their bedroom habits…you may have too much time on your hands and may want to pick up a hobby.