Philadelphia to host national gay rights rally
05.01.2009 3:48pm EDT
(Philadelphia) Lilli Vincenz started demonstrating for gay rights at Independence Hall in the 1960s, when the activists had a strict no-hippies dress code: suits and ties for men, dresses or skirts for women.
In the fight against workplace discrimination, Vincenz said, “we were supposed to look employable.”The dress code won’t be the only thing that has changed when Vincenz, 71, returns to Philadelphia this weekend for the National Equality Rally. The event planned for Sunday is being billed as the first national demonstration since 2000 for gay, lesbian, bisexual and transgender rights and the first to be held outside Washington.
“We are at the tipping point of the GLBT civil rights movement,” said Malcolm Lazin, executive director of the Philadelphia-based Equality Forum, which is sponsoring the event. “This is a movement that will not let up.”
Supporters will have much to cheer. Nine years ago – before the last march on the National Mall in Washington – Vermont had just passed the country’s first civil-unions law. Today, gays can marry in Vermont, Connecticut, Iowa and Massachusetts; bills are pending in several other states.
But gay rights advocates also say there is much work to do. Demonstrators will call for same-sex marriage equality nationwide; for including transgendered individuals in federal anti-discrimination and hate crime laws; and for repealing the Defense of Marriage Act and the military’s “Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell” policy.
Organizers plan a march circling the blocks around Independence Hall and the Liberty Bell, followed by a one-hour rally.
“It is important for our community to come together to celebrate our lives and our accomplishments as well as to push for further inclusion in the nation’s promises of liberty and equality for everyone,” said Jennifer Manion, director of student services for the gay community at Connecticut College.
The symbolism of Philadelphia, where all men were declared created equal, was just as powerful to Vincenz and Frank Kameny, who organized the first “Annual Reminder Day Picket” for gay rights on July 4, 1965, at Independence Hall.
Kameny, a World War II combat veteran, said he lost his job with the U.S. Army’s map service in 1957 because he is gay. The pickets were designed “to remind the public that there’s still one large group of people who are not having their rights protected, and are still being subject to prejudice and discrimination without remedy,” he said.
Activists demanded an end to anti-gay bias in federal civil service employment and the removal of homosexuality from the American Psychiatric Association’s list of mental disorders, among other issues.
The first picket was held four years before the landmark Stonewall riots in New York, considered the birth of the gay rights movement. It drew between 25 and 40 people, according to Kameny and Vincenz. By the time the fifth one was held in 1969, just as Stonewall was ending, about 150 people attended.
Today’s gay rights rallies, which can draw tens of thousands, involve issues “we never would have conceived back then,” Kameny said.
Now 83 and living in Washington, Kameny will return on Sunday to the site of the “annual reminders,” which are now commemorated by a state historical marker.
By any measure, the gay rights movement has achieved “remarkable success” in the 40 years since Stonewall, Manion said. But those victories mask deeper-rooted problems with homophobia, especially as experienced by adolescents too young to benefit from same-sex marriage or job anti-bias laws, she said.
“Young people … are still subject to the beliefs and whims of their parents,” Manion said. “All the stigmas are still the same.”
Vincenz, though, said she is optimistic about the future. She looks forward to visiting Philadelphia for the march and rally – while wearing a pair of “nice slacks.”
“I just feel ecstatic about the younger generation and what they’re doing,” Vincenz said. “There’s a groundswell of people who finally feel empowered, that they can make a difference.”




As a person living on the “left coast” I feel totally let down just now finding out. Could it have hurt to let everyone, nationwide, know? I would have been there!
well i agree. i keep up with ALL the gay events and news and i PARTICIPATE and i WRITE senators, congress people, etc. and this is TRULY first i have heard of this! so “Menstruator” you will have to be man enough and march for me too sista boy.
go get em. i am definately too far away to make it. i will look for info. about the turn out from you and others about it on the big world wide web…
peace to you and all.
huh? a “national” rally. i’m a totally plugged in ‘mo and this is the first i’ve heard of this event.
Obviously this is not really a national event. If it were, the organizers would have notified all the major gay blogs and websites months ago. People need weeks, if not months, to plan to go to an event like this. Very disappointing.
I agree with GrrrlRomeo. I try to stay informed. I even work for a newspaper and set up wire alerts to look for news of gay-related events. The first mention of this rally came through at 12:23p.m. Friday.
That doesn’t allow a lot of time to arrange for respite care for my invalid mother and make travel arrangements.
If it’s truly a “national” event, then people need time to make airline and hotel reservations. Forty-eight hours notice doesn’t cut it.
I read gay news everyday (not just 365gay), several gay blogs, connected on Facebook and Twitter and this is the first I’ve heard of this.
It is absolutely not a “National” Rally if half the gay population doesn’t know about it and thus doesn’t have the opportunity to attend. This is some top down organizing bullshit astroturfing.
Folks,
It’s not 365gay. It’s self-loving Malcolm Lazin. Though he’s put together an “international” rally and education week, he can’t even get the local gay rag to advertise it, chooses to stay away from the gayborhood and cannot attract the highest quality speakers (oh, they are good, but there are even better folks available.). But what can we expect from someone who thinks Republican greed is good for society?
Never a mention of queer youth safety and suicide. military and marriage blah blah blah. sad.
Men-straighter said: You gotta make it a point to be in the know about stuff like this. It’s not like it was a secret. You have to know this stuff or the breeders win!!!
And how the blooooody c+nt f**ck is anyone suppose to know this without support news sites like this one advertising it? By osmosis? Viral dispersment? We don’t, you know, have a tele-kenetic grapevine. So, just get over yourself and try to be kinder and more helpful in the future by sharing what you know so we will “just know this stuff” like you do. With out prior broad notice, the staights don’t win; We lose.
I echo the sentiments of the other writers…Gee gosh, I wish I had known. I’m a lot farther away than 60 miles.
I completely agree with The Menstruator. While I appreciate 365gay.com giving us excellent news coverage, we also have the responsibility to maintain our own understanding/knowledge of current events.
Good luck, everyone!
Listen. 365gay isn’t in charge of your gay agenda. You gotta make it a point to be in the know about stuff like this. It’s not like it was a secret. You have to know this stuff or the breeders win!!!
I’ll be there marching strong and lezzie.
yeah, this was poorly planned. it sounds like something that myself and many friends would like to take part in but there was like no mention anywhere about this (unless it was just local?). a little heads up and they could have probably at least doubled their numbers.
Yeah, I was wondering why it wasn’t advertised better, but that’s the Malcolm Lazin for you. Still, I think the turnout should be impressive. You should come anyway. 60 miles is worth the trip, and there’s going to be quite a bit of pomp and circumstance.
And you let people know the night before?
Thanks for the non-advanced notice, being 60 miles away I would have attended if I had heard about it a week or month ago. Sheesh!
According to the metro, 38,000 people are expected to turn out. Hope to see ya’ll there.