March 19th, 2010
 

365 Gay: News

Palestinian files $110M libel suit over ‘Bruno’


(Washington) A Palestinian shopkeeper and father portrayed as a terrorist in the movie “Bruno” is suing film star Sacha Baron Cohen, David Letterman and others for libel and slander.

The lawsuit filed last week by Ayman Abu Aita in District of Columbia federal court seeks $110 million in damages.

In the movie, Baron Cohen plays a gay Austrian fashion journalist trying to make it big in the United States. To achieve worldwide fame, Bruno travels to the Middle East to make peace. He interviews Abu Aita, and a caption labels the Bethlehem shopkeeper as a member of the militant Al-Aqsa Martyrs’ Brigade.

Abu Aita is suing CBS and Letterman’s company Worldwide Pants over an interview before the film’s release where the Late Show host and Baron Cohen discussed Bruno’s encounter with a “terrorist.”

In the interview, Baron Cohen, 37, said he set up the meeting in the West Bank with the help of a CIA agent. Baron Cohen said he feared for his safety and interviewed the “terrorist” at a secret location chosen by Abu Aita. A clip was then played on “The Late Show with David Letterman.”

According to the lawsuit, however, the interview with Abu Aita took place at a hotel chosen by Baron Cohen and located in a part of the West Bank that was under Israeli military control.

Film distributor NBC Universal and director Larry Charles are also named in the lawsuit.

A spokeswoman for Universal Studios declined to comment. Tom Keaney, a spokesman for David Letterman, also said he would not comment.

Baron Cohen, a British comedian, also faced multiple lawsuits after his earlier movie, “Borat,” including one for $30 million filed by residents of a remote Romanian village who said they were misled into thinking the project was a documentary about poverty. Most of the lawsuits were thrown out.

Abu Aita is prominent businessman, a Christian and a “peace-loving person who abhors violence,” the latest lawsuit states. Before the film, he “enjoyed a good reputation for honesty and a peaceable nature” in his community, Abu Aita’s lawyers wrote.

They go on to write that any accusations or insinuations that Abu Aita is or ever was associated with the Al-Aqsa Martyrs’ Brigade, or any other terrorist activity is “utterly false and untrue.”

Attorney Joseph Peter Drennan said Abu Aita was never offered a release to sign to appear in the film.

“This is an important lawsuit because it is about the dignity of a specific person. It is about his reputation, about his standing in the community,” Drennan said.

“It addresses a very corrosive and calumnious slur against any young Palestinian who would be a political activist on the West Bank” who would be called a “terrorist” because of his activism.

Hatem Abu Ahmad, Abu Aita’s Arab-Israeli lawyer, said Baron Cohen made millions “on the back of my client.”

The film drew disdain from the Israelis and Palestinians portrayed in a place Bruno calls “Middle Earth.”

Abu Ahmad has said the gay associations in the movie could cause danger for Abu Aita.

“This joke is very dangerous. We are not in the United States, we are not in Europe,” he said. “We are in the Middle East and the world operates differently here.”

An Alabama pastor who tries to talk Bruno out of being gay in the movie has said he was duped into appearing in the film through phone calls and fake Internet sites set up by Baron Cohen’s cohorts. Pastor Jody Trautwein believed he was helping a German TV crew.

Drennan said he expects a hearing on the Abu Aita’s complaint in late January.


Login or Register to comment.

or Login with Facebook:

  • 00HaveAniceDay00 Said: December 10th, 2009 at 11:53 am
    • Good ! I hope this guy wins. It really bothers me when the media portrays gay people in this manner. When are they going to portray being as gay as cool and not so stereotypical?

  • DaveW Said: December 10th, 2009 at 12:22 pm
    • haveaniceday: I think you should remember this was a movie…a comedy. Yes, movies are a “medium” but generally your comment is read to mean the media involved in journalism. I agree with your comment regardless.

      I did not see either movie, I rarely watch comedies and never those targeted at the lowest common denominator. The trailers for Borat made it clear I would not find it funny and the hype around this latest attempt informed me not only would I not laugh, I’d likely be insulted.

      But I did listen to Terry Gross interview him, and I was appalled at the tactics. His producers lied to get influential people to sit for interviews and then lampooned them. This is beyond “candid camera”, which I always found in incredible poor taste, because he is not merely setting up a situation and seeing what happens, he is misleading people into thinking they are doing something totally different.

      If that is what it takes to make humor, I’m not interested. Mr. Cohen did not say in the interview that he was trying to get at some universal truth, he was trying to make good humor.

      It says a lot about our society that this junk is considered just that, because it is not. The ends do not justify the means (especially if the ends are never achieved) and labelling a real person..a christian no less, as a member of the al Aqsa martyrs brigade is indeed libelous in my opinion.

  • Morgan Said: December 10th, 2009 at 12:47 pm
    • Being gay in some conservative Middle Eastern lands like Saudi Arabia or Iran can be your death sentence. You cannot be gay in Palestinian Arab territory without possible harm to yourself. Why are gay Palestinian Arabs trying to flee to Israel? for that reason. This shopping has much to fear from his own society if thought gay even if he isn’t. Being gay in the Middle East is much different from being gay in say Iceland, Norway, Sweden or Denmark, etc. I support this angry lawsuit from this Palestinian man.

  • Drewski Said: December 10th, 2009 at 1:04 pm
    • Uhm, al-Aqsa is a MUSLIM organization. If there’s one thing you can count on in Palestine, it is that people are acutely aware of who belongs to which religion. As it happens, there’s a sizable Palestinian population in Cleveland, and the first wave of them were Christians who were essentially pushed out because the Jews and Muslims didn’t want them as an obstacle to their eternal squabbling. So Israel knows he’s not a terrorist, and the various Muslim factions know he’s not one of them, and the remaining Palestinian Christians know him from his presence as a businessman, not a bomb-toting hothead. I can see the argument for a lawsuit based on harm done to his reputation, but where is the actual harm? This article provides no specific examples of actual damage–harassment, threats, broken shop windows, vandalism of his home, threats to his family. None of this is present in this article.

  • Adrian Quir Said: December 10th, 2009 at 1:06 pm
    • It’s a mockumentary, not a documentary. If it were presented as a documentary, then scream bloody libel. Sure, Bruno is a commentary of how society can be, but that doesn’t mean it’s a freaking news source.

      If you want to go after someone, go after Glen Beck and all those liars at Faux News.

 
Login

Register
Lost your password?


or Login with Facebook