NY school sued by Lambda Legal agrees to GSA
04.20.2009 11:26am EDT
(Philadelphia, New York) Just days after a federal lawsuit was filed against the Indian River Central School District, the District has agreed to allow Ashley Petranchuk to form a Gay-Straight Alliance.
The suit, filed last week, claimed that Charlie Pratt endured years of anti-gay harassment during his time at Indian River High School, and his sister Ashley suffered the same bias at the same high school years after her brother left.The school is located in Philadelphia, New York, northeast of Watertown.
Both Ashley and Charlie are represented by Lambda Legal and attorneys from the law firm Kirkland & Ellis. The suit was filed at the US District Court for the Northern District of New York.
“After years of denying students like Ashley, her brother Charlie and others their right to form a GSA, Indian River is taking an important first step toward righting its wrongs,” said Lambda Legal attorney Michael Kavey.
“Respecting students’ freedom to stand up for themselves and each other is a key part of creating a safe learning environment for lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender youth and their allies.”
The lawsuit said that Charlie Pratt was severely harassed throughout his time in the school district. Students attacked him relentlessly with anti-,gay and sexist slurs including names like “faggot,” “sissy,” “queer,” and “fudgepacker,” often in the presence of teachers who failed to intervene.
Students also are alleged to have pushed Charlie into walls and lockers, threatened him, threw food and other objects at him, spat on him, and vandalized his locker with anti-gay slurs. Staff members at the high school joined the harassment by ridiculing Charlie with stereotypically effeminate gestures in front of other students, according to the suit.
Then-principal James Kettrick — now the district’s superintendent — refused to take appropriate action, and instead told Charlie and his parents, Bobbi and Todd Petranchuk, that Charlie should “tone it down” to avoid harassment, Lambda Legal said in a media statement at the time the lawsuit was filed.
Lambda said that the principal refused Bobbi Petranchuk’s request to train teachers to address anti-gay bullying, and he failed to change the school’s written policies to match state anti-harassment laws covering sexual orientation. Left with no other options, Charlie’s parents withdrew him from school for his own protection, the suit said.
“We hope the District’s statement that it will finally allow the GSA signals an effort to fully address the discriminatory atmosphere at the schools,” said Sudwiti Chanda, a partner in the New York offices of Kirkland. ”We will work with Ashley to ensure that the District follows through on its promise to promote tolerance and inclusiveness by providing support, and equal opportunity and treatment to the GSA.”
While the District’s approval of a GSA addresses some aspects of the lawsuit, Lambda and Kirkland & Ellis said they will press forward with other claims, including claims for damages on behalf of both plaintiffs. The lawsuit seeks damages for Charlie for violations of the federal Constitution’s Equal Protection Clause and Free Speech Clause, as well as for violations of Title IX, the Federal Equal Access Act, and New York state antidiscrimination laws.





I am glad that the lawsuit against the school district continues. I hope it has to pay a lot of money for the damage it enabled bullies to inflict on Charlie.
Sock it to them!
“Staff members at the high school joined the harassment by ridiculing Charlie with stereotypically effeminate gestures in front of other students”.
Hope these teachers weren’t “Christians”!
GOOD – Its about time
History proves that speaking to the school about bullying behaviour accomplishes nothing, as this story shows. In future anyone who is subjected to this type of treatment, especially at the hands of staff, should sue the perpetrator and the sdchool. If they won’t change their homophobic behaviour voluntarily, then hit them where it hurts most – in the pocket.
What about a lawsuit for failing to uphold NYs policies on harrassment and bullying?
The treatment of this student is atrocious! Why aren’t the administrators and the teachers being held accountable. Why aren’t the police being called in for the assault(s)?
Although the GSA portion of the lawsuit will help to foster an environment of safety for the future, this kid needed help due to bullying! It’s a shame this student was forced to leave school for his safety. Absolutely no excuse for this sort of behavior from other students and certainly the “adults” charged with protecting ALL children in their care!
YAY! Thank you Ashley and Charlie. That was very brave, and a lot of people are going to benefit from your leadership! And thank you Lamda Legal for helping them. Thank goodness more GSA’s are able to come about in high schools. Thanks again Ashley and Charlie!
The agreement to allow a GSA is clearly an effort to mitigate the damages that the school’s lawyers have told them they face for the principal’s outrageous criminal neglect the the staff’s complete bigotry. I hope they get a huge judgment that sends a message to other hateful vermin infesting our schools.
I know Charlie, He is actually the first person I came out to. I hope All goes well for him and his sister.
Of course the school, I am sure, was giving full rights to christian / catholic groups if asked.
All part of the near destruction of our civil society by George the damned Bush, Satan himself, and his pals in the religious right. Good riddance to them, and to their party if it doesn’t find the balls to tell those people where to go.
And cheers for the legal teams. The hatred for gays, no matter how cleverly couched by the religious right, is just an example of the monstrosity of conservative religions. Which are what spawns things like 9/11, the hatred of the Jews that gave hitler the 2nd lever he needed to gain control of germany. Nice people, in the Name of God, no less.
The school system was smart. School systems have just about a 100% failure rate in trying to deny GSAs.