Neff: Bigger than the moonwalk
I remember the summer of 1969.
I was five years old and bound for kindergarten in the fall.
For my birthday in May of that year I received my first wooden Louisville Slugger bat and a Franklin baseball glove.By June I had suffered my first significant sports injury. I was catching a pickup game in the neighborhood and caught a split lip when the batter threw my first Louisville Slugger.
I remember well that event in the summer of 1969 because I drank milkshakes for two days.
And I remember gathering with my family to watch Apollo 11 landing on the moon, a live transmission from the moon to our television set.
My parents told me the moon landing would change the world, would change my life in ways I could not imagine.
I don’t remember anyone that summer mentioning Stonewall or that the riots outside that New York club would change the world, would change lives, would change my life in ways I could not imagine.
My parents probably saw a news report that Judy Garland had died, but they probably did not hear or read the short reports about the six nights of rioting. They were a long way from Greenwich Village and a current issue of The New York Times or Village Voice.
My parents, like many young Midwestern parents living on tomato soup and tuna casserole in their first suburban home, probably would not have quite grasped the meaning of the headline in the New York Daily News — “Homo nest raided. Queen bees are stinging mad.”
Stonewall took about 15 years or more to impact me and my family, but the event, with its long-lasting after-shocks, did influence my life in far more ways than Apollo 11’s landing on the moon.
When I came out, I came out into a community that, forged in Stonewall, had rioted and rebelled, protested and pushed, marched and rallied at capitols in most states and on the National Mall.
When I came out, I came out into a community that, following Stonewall, felt liberated and proclaimed pride. Think about Allen Ginsberg’s comment about the gay men he saw on Christopher Street after Stonewall — “They’ve lost that wounded look that fags all had 10 years ago.”
When I came out, I came out to friends and family aware and awakened by the modern movement that Stonewall spurred.
From Stonewall came gay power and from gay power came gay pride. And from gay pride the community learned to use its power, to build influence, to force change — social change, cultural change, political change.
Now, years after coming out, I realize the Stonewall riots even made possible my day-to-day domestic tranquility —though not yet equality — that my partner and I enjoy with our neighbors and co-workers.
Perhaps the most rebellious of readers might think this a sad comment, but I realize too that Stonewall helped pave the way for young gay Midwestern parents to start out like my parents — to be living happily in the summer of 2009 on tomato soup and tuna casserole and raising their 5-year-old daughter in their first suburban home.
My memories of 1969 are of baseball and new sneakers for school, learning to never talk to strangers and watching a goofy new show about “The Brady Bunch,” and finding my way to North Elementary School and thinking about walking on the moon.
My memories of 1969 are not of the Stonewall riots, or news of the riots, or talk of the riots. Years would pass before I would hear of Stonewall and even then I had to struggle to understand the concept of police harassment — because Stonewall had already forced some reform.
Stonewall is nowhere in my child’s memory of 1969, but Stonewall, that event that went unnoticed in the small Neff household that year, changed my life and the lives of so many others born then and born after.
Thank you, Stonewall generation.
And happy pride.






Stonewall. Yes. Bigger than the moonwalk. Longer lasting than the Summer of Love. More significant than any event in all my life. Thanks.
The first public gay rights organization in the U.S. was the Society for Human Rights (SHR) in 1924, organized by Henry Gerber, who was soon arrested. Organization attempts continued and the Mattachine Society emerged in 1950, followed by Daughters of Bilitis organized by Del Martin and Phyllis Lyon (the first couple married in California)and others, in San Francisco in 1955. In August of 1966, the Compton Cafeteria riot in San Francisco, helped set the precedent for Stonewall. By 1969 gay and lesbian organizations existed all over the country. Stonewall was an important milestone because it was the first time the national media paid attention, but it was not the birth of the gay equal rights movement in the U.S. It is important to remember that the struggle for equality started long before 1969, and many were arrested, beaten and killed. The hard work and sacrifice of those who preceded Stonewall should not be underestimated or forgotten.
wow-i was 7 years old living in a small northern calif mountain town, i remember the moon landing, i remember dear Judy dying, i was sad that Dorothy died and but the wicked witch was still alive! Stonewall? riots in New York? Never heard of em them in our small town. we got 2 tv stations & a local paper, nothin i can recall in those about stonewall. But here we are 40 years later me and my husband are married!
(thanks Cal supreme ct for letting us keep our marriage lic—as for the rest of your ruling this is a family website!)
Hats off to the patrons of the stonewall, i am forever grateful!
I was 43 years old in 1969 and out. And I can tell you, there were gay organizations and actions before Stonewall but there was NOT a modern gay rights movement. I am as grateful to the Stonewall rioters for launching the movement as the generations that came after Stonewall.
Yes, Amy, Stonewall was a very important milestone, but it is often treated as if it came out of nowhere, and as if there was no gay rights movement before then. I too, am grateful for the Stonewall rioters, but I am also grateful for those who sacrificed their jobs, freedom and lives laying the groundwork that led up to Stonewall. Again, their sacrifice should not be ignored and forgotten, as it is so often.
What a wonder, upbeat column. I can’t imagine reading anything more uplifting to start this holiday weekend. Thak you Ms. Neff.
I was nine years old, but by age 29, I was reading all about Stonewall and the effects became clear: In a society that expected us to be ashamed of who were are, we sent back a hearty, “No thank you, we’re proud actually, and plan to stay that way.”
I was 26 the day of the Stonewall riots. I hit the bars in NYC in 1961 when I turned 18. I left NYC in 1966 when gay life became dodgeing constant harrassment by NYPD. Many of us were getting fed-up with the city closing down our gay bars, like during and after the mayoral elections of 1964. I couldn’t find a gay bar to go into, so I did the next best thing, hung out on the streets in the village. When word spread that a bar had just opened, we all went, but most were short lived. It took the riots at the Stonewall to change all of our lives, take pride in who we are, not just in the USA but all around the world. Thanks guys and gals………. Ted
I wish I was alive back then so I could join in protesting with the gays for gay rights in New York and then watch the moonlanding!!!!!
I was 24 in the summer of 1969 and living in Downey, California. I had just come out in the summer of 1968. In August, 1969 I moved back to NY and although I hung out in the gay bars on LI, I never heard of Stonewall until June, 1970 when I was standing in the J&M Lounge in Mineola, LI and someone came in passing out leaflets about a march that was going to take place in NYC the last Sunday in June. I got together with several other friends from LI and we went into that march. I got involved with the Gay Activists Alliance right afer that. That changed my life. I want to thank that anonymous person who handed me that leaflet that day in that bar on Long Island. I’ve been involved in the movement in some way ever since. The changes I’ve seen in those years are amazing. Never dreamed that at this point we would actually see gay marriage legal in some states. Yet we still have so far to go. And we do have people like Barbara Gittings, Franklin Kameny and Troy Perry to thank, who came before Stonewall and helped lay the groundwork for this movement.
I wasn’t even thought of yet, and was born in 73. I am thankful to all of the men, & women who fought for their rights to live freely in America. I am glad to see that equal marriage is accepted in most Northeastern states, but here in Florida? I don’t think I will be alive to see it happen. I do think that the GLBT community will receive equality here in the USA, but it’s going to take alot more blood, sweat, & tears. So bless all of the people still fighting for our rights, in the past, present & future.
GO GLBT community, GO!!
Hello Lisa:
Thank you. I remember the moon landing. I remember the fuzzy images from the moon, being seen live on my parent’s T.V. Thanks for the time warp!!
I think I started school in 1969 or 1970.
Tom in Long Beach.
Well I was alittle over 1 yr. old , and frankly didn’t much pay attention I guess if it is even in the history books in my area. One of the most anti-gay places in Rhode Island , where you still have to look over your shoulder before you even say anything about being gay. I still think unfortunately we have a long ways to go , we’ve still got millions of people out of work , we’re still giving billions to companies who should have went under years ago . As for the funding for Aids and us we’re outta luck we have to get the country stable first before any healthcare will ever be available I wouldn’t hold mine or your breath , as for Stonewall I will have to look further into that….
Thank you….for while you were young and drinking milkshakes, I was a graduate student drinking Dewars….and often at the Stonewall Inn in the Village from 1967 on….
Thanks, and wasn’t that moonwalk still wonderful, eh?
Bigger than which moonwalk?
Buzz or Michael’s or Both?