Lesbian student in Miss. fights for tuxedo photo
10.16.2009 11:39am EDT
(Jackson, Miss.) Everyone at Wesson Attendance Center knows 17-year-old Ceara Sturgis is gay because she’s never tried to hide it.
But when Sturgis – an honor student, trumpet player and goalie on the school’s soccer team – wanted her senior photograph in a tuxedo used in the 2009-10 yearbook, school officials balked. Traditionally, female students dress in drapes and males wear tuxedos.Now, the American Civil Liberties Union of Mississippi has gotten involved, issuing a demand letter to Principal Ronald Greer to publish the picture of Sturgis in the tuxedo. The ACLU says it’s giving the school until Oct. 23 to respond before pursuing court action, said Kristy L. Bennett, the ACLU’s legal director.
A secretary for Greer referred questions to Copiah County Schools Superintendent Rickey Clopton, who declined to comment on Thursday.
Sturgis said she should get to decide how she looks in the senior photo.
“I feel like I’m not important, that the school is dismissing who I am as a gay student and that they don’t even care about me. All I want is to be able to be me, and to be included in the yearbook,” Sturgis said in a statement.
Veronica Rodriguez, 47, said school officials are trying to force her daughter – who doesn’t even own a dress – to appear more feminine.
“The tux is who she is. She wears boys’ clothes. She’s athletic. She’s gay. She’s not feminine,” said Rodriguez during an interview Thursday at the ACLU office.
Rodriguez said Sturgis took her pictures over the summer instead of with the other students last year, but she used the same studio.
In August, Rodriguez said she received a letter from the school stating that only boys could wear tuxedos. Rodriguez said she met with assistant Superintendent Ronald Holloway who told her he didn’t see regulations about the issue in the student handbook.
But when she talked with Greer, she said he told her it was his “conviction” that Sturgis wouldn’t appear in the yearbook in a tuxedo.
Bennett said the teenager’s constitutional rights are being violated. Bennett said similar cases, including same-sex prom couples and girls wearing tuxedos to proms, have been successfully challenged in court in other states. ACLU officials said they were unaware of any other constitutional disputes involving gay teens at Mississippi schools.
“You can’t discriminate against somebody because they’re not masculine enough or because they’re not feminine enough. She’s making an expression of her sexual orientation through this picture and that invokes First Amendment protection,” Bennett said.
There’s no state policy that deals with the yearbook photo issue, said state Department of Education spokesman Pete Smith.
The deadline for the photo to be accepted for the yearbook was Sept. 30. But advertisements for the publication are still being taken so Sturgis has time for her photo to be included, Bennett said.
Sturgis lives with her grandparents in Wesson, a town of about 1,700 founded during the Civil War in southwest Mississippi. The town’s Web site said residents “pride ourselves on our quiet way of life.”




for crying out loud……it’s just a damn picture…….who cares what she is wearing…..let her wear the tux…..
More and more I’ve discovered that people are so unwilling to revise tradition because for some reason (lack of open-mindedness? unconscious bigotry?) they cannot see how certain traditions are unequal or excluding of certain groups.
I’ve noticed this recently at my own university, where the student government association voted down proposed legislation to allow same-sex couples to run for homecoming (here couples run for king and queen, prince and princess, duke and duchess, and lord and lady). And they’re not interested in reconsidering the legislation even after a protest that interrupted their meeting. They just say that homecoming is equal because a guy who is gay can run for king or a girl who is gay can run for queen. (But the other way around is not acceptable.) It’s still one man and one woman pairs but to them, there’s complete equality.
Both that request to be more representative of the LGBT community and this request for a girl to appear in her yearbook (a place for her and her classmates’ memories) in a tux do not hurt anyone by being accepted. They only give non-heteronormative images a little more exposure, which should only be worrying homophobics.
http://gladuntblog.blogspot.com/
ok this young woman played sports for the glory of the school did they complain she wasn’t “lady like enough” then?Funny how when it benifited them she was great but when it came to honoring this great student athleat she is disrespected.
at least the aclu is good for something besides defending those who harrass & torment us!
It’s great to see that she has the support of her family in dealing with this issue.
She should consider starting something where all the girls wear a tux. Maybe even guys wearing a dress. Its not like she is trying to offend or dress outside of the context of the event. Her principal / school administration needs to grow up.
I’m glad the principal is burning his on-the-clock time on a girl wearing a tux, as opposed to…oh, I dunno…DOING HIS JOB. Especially in a state with the worst school funding in the country. Ceara Sturgis has already shown herself to be above average, and it says something that her classmates don’t have an issue with her wearing a tux. It doesn’t seem to occur to the principal that he’s undermining the authority of his position with such a petty squabble.
So, if tux’s are for “boys” and drapes are for “girls”, then what is the school’s policy on intersexed children? I mean they are apparently so concerned with the student’s genitalia matching their wardrobe. Oh, and I knew girls at my school who wore tux’s to the prom. Personally I think androgyny is beautiful. Something so sexy about a woman in a nice crisp tux!
It is wonderful that the mother is supportive of her daughter because that’s just the right thing to do.
It is just ridiculous that in this day and age this is still an issue. As for a woman in a tux, works for me!
Standing up (ok, sitting down) for our rights!
It is wonderful that the mother is supportive of her daughter because that’s just the right thing to do.
It is just ridiculous that in this day and age this is still an issue. As for a woman in a tux, works for me!
Standing up (ok, sitting down) for our rights!
MOST IMPORTANTLY:
Kudos and PROPS go out to this fantastic MOM, who is willing to stand up and support her daughter, loving her for who she is.
I wish I’d had a mom like this. It would have saved 20 years of heartbreak, confusion and a failed marriage if someone had let me know it was ok to be gay.
Props to you, Veronica! Supertastic mom.
I am seeing that more and more christian groups are complaining that the LGBT Community should have no rights. Well What would they say if they had to pay taxs on the gounds that there chruch’s or just taxs period. They already are listed and a non profit org. why what makes them special. What if we closed our walets, and stopped paying taxes to support them. if all the tax money that we made as a gay community stayed it would look really bad it would look segragated all over again like black and white,was many years ago. and no look history is repeating itself. Our government would fall in a huge hole if the LGBT Community bannded together and took a stand for who we are. every day i read more and more about what is happening to the LGBT Community and keep thinking that we are headed right for another Stone Wall of history and it will be bigger than the last one and more devistaing than the last one. Churchs wanted the state to be seporate well then stay out of political issues. other wise lets reverse the law that states that church and state are seporate. and make it the way is use to be. So the next question in my mind is ..
At what cost will it take for Equality
We are a nation of freedom and I see no freedom when I am told No to some thing that is MY RIGHT.
>douchebag
I love this word. Cracks me up every time.
…and women in tuxedos look fan-TAS-tic. Marlene Dietrich, anyone?
What’s the saying? “Why are women in tuxedos always sexy and men in dresses always funny?” (Apologies in advance to serious and realistic drag…I don’t think this applies to you.)
How come every time it’s either homecoming or prom season there are stories like this? Why do administrations care if kids wear tuxes? Are there not more important issues at that school?
http://stuffqueerpeopleneedtoknow.wordpress.com
I just wanna say her mom sounds awesome.
Wow, that principal is such a douchebag. It’s just a picture and it seems that everyone else accepts that the tux suits her more; I don’t see what the problem is other than that the principal is narrow-minded and can’t stand anything he deems as imperfection in the senior photos. Feh, mistakes will happen anyways; my senior year book was plagued with incorrect spellings of names.
I never got my senior photo taken so I don’t know what it would have been like at my school for that, but I know that my principal had absolutely no problem with me wearing the boys’ dress code to graduation.