Jamaican gays warn against US boycott
04.14.2009 6:23pm EDT
(Kingston) Jamaica’s largest LGBT civil rights group is asking American gays to reject a boycott of Jamaica and Jamaican products.
US rights group TruthWinsOut, founded by 365gay columnist Wayne Besen, has called for a boycott of the island and some of its most famous products, to protest several violent homophobic incidents and Jamaica’s refusal to repeal laws against sodomy.Wednesday, the group will launch a national boycott of Jamaica in New York City at the famed Stonewall Bar – birthplace of the gay rights movement. TruthWinsOut leader Besen said that the bar’s owners and boycott supporters will dump Jamaican liquor – Red Stripe beer and Myers’ Rum – down the sewer.
“We, as the owners of the Stonewall Inn, birthplace of the Gay rights movement, refuse to support, in any way, shape or form, the oppression of any people especially our gay brothers and sisters in Jamaica,” the Stonewall Inn said in its statement.
“We ask all people of all walks of life to send a clear message to the Jamaican people and their government, that as long as they continue to allow and condone violence and hatred toward the Gay community, we will neither buy their products nor support their tourist trade.”
“If you love your gay friends and family members, you won’t visit Jamaica,” said boycott co-organizer Wayne Besen. “If you care about the human rights of gay, lesbian, bisexual and transgender people, you won’t buy Jamaican products. We hope that all gay and gay friendly bar owners and restaurateurs across the nation will participate in ‘rum dumps.’ We can no longer subsidize our own slaughter.”
But in Kingston, the Jamaica Forum for Lesbians All-Sexuals and Gays, said the boycott could backfire and result in more violence.
“Because of the possible repercussions of increased homophobic violence against our already besieged community, we feel that a tourist boycott is not the most appropriate response at this time,” J-FLAG said in a statement.
“In our battle to win hearts and minds, we do not wish to be perceived as taking food off the plate of those who are already impoverished. In fact, members of our own community could be disproportionately affected by a worsened economic situation brought about by a tourist ban.”
Jamaican Prime Minister Bruce Golding has told Parliament his government will not yield to “perhaps the most organized lobby in the world” and will not abolish prison sentences for sodomy.
Golding made the comment during debate on a new sexual offenses law primarily aimed at combating rape and child abuse. Jamaican LGBT rights groups and international human rights organizations had urged the government to include a repeal of the sodomy law in the new act.
Gay sex is punishable by up to seven years in prison under a law which dates back to British colonial rule. Britain has long since abolished the law and has urged its former colonies to do the same.
Jamaica has been described by human rights groups as having the worst record of any country in the New World in its treatment of gays and lesbians.
In January 2008, a group of men approached a house where four males lived in the central Jamaican town of Mandeville, and demanded that they leave the community because they were gay, according to Jamaican human rights activists who spoke with the victims.
Later that evening, a mob returned and surrounded the house. The four men inside called the police when they saw the crowd gathering. The mob started to attack the house, shouting and throwing bottles.
Those in the house called police again and were told that the police were on the way. Approximately half an hour later, 15-20 men broke down the door and began beating and slashing the inhabitants.
Human Rights Watch, quoting local activists said that police did not arrive until a half hour after the mob had broken into the house – 90 minutes after the men first called for help.
One of the victims managed to flee with the mob pursuing. A Jamaican newspaper reported that blood was found at the mouth of a nearby pit, suggesting he had fallen inside or may have been killed nearby.
The police escorted the three other victims away from the scene; two of them were taken to the hospital. One of the men had his left ear severed, his arm broken in two places, and his spine reportedly damaged.
There have been no arrests.
The attack echoes another incident in the same town on Easter Sunday, April 8, 2007 when approximately 100 men gathered outside a church where 150 people were attending the funeral of a gay man.
According to mourners, the crowd broke the windows with bottles and shouted, “We want no battyman [gay] funeral here. Leave or else we’re going to kill you. We don’t want no battyman buried here in Mandeville.”
Several mourners inside the church called the police to request protection. After half an hour, three police officers arrived.
Human Rights Watch said that instead of protecting the mourners, police socialized with the mob, laughing along at the situation.
A highway patrol car subsequently arrived, and one of the highway patrol officers reportedly told the churchgoers, “It’s full time this needs to happen. Enough of you guys.”
The highway patrol officers then drove off. The remaining officers at the scene refused to intervene when the mob threatened the mourners with sticks, stones, and batons as they tried to leave the service. Only when several gay men among the mourners took knives from their cars for self-defense did police reportedly take action by firing their guns into the air. Officers stopped gay men from leaving and searched their vehicles, but did not restrain or detain members of the mob, Human Rights Watch said.
More than 30 gay men are believed to have been murdered since 1997 J-FLAG says. In most of the cases the killers have never been brought to trial.
Arrests, however, have been made in several cases which received international attention.
In 2004, Brian Williamson, Jamaica’s leading LGBT civil rights advocate, was brutally murdered. He had been stabbed at least 70 times in the neck. A 25-year-old man is currently serving a life sentence for the murder.
In December 2005, Lenford “Steve” Harvey who ran Jamaica AIDS Support for Life was killed.
Harvey was shot to death on the eve of World AIDS Day. His organization provided support to gay men and sex workers. Four men were arrested almost a year later.
In 2006, the bodies of two women believed to have been in a lesbian relationship were found dumped in a septic pit behind a home they shared. The killers of Candice Williams and Phoebe Myrie have not been caught.
Students at University of the West Indies in Kingston rioted last year as police attempted to protect a gay student and escort him from the campus. The incident began when the student was chased across the campus by another student who claimed the gay man had attempted to proposition him in a washroom.
The same year, a young man plunged to his death off a pier in Kingston after reportedly being chased through the streets by a mob yelling homophobic epithets.
In February 2007, three men in “tight jeans” and wearing what some witnesses described as makeup were cornered by a mob of 2000 in a drugstore. There were yells of “kill them” along with gay slurs and demands the three be sent out “to face justice.” Police had to fire tear gas into the crowd to rescue the three.
Reggae, or Jamaican dancehall music, is blamed for fueling homophobia. Reggae star BujuBanton’s hit song Boom Boom Bye Bye which threatens gay men with a “gunshot in ah head.”





I am still boycotting. I am tired of being polite and tired of trying to be the bigger person. Enough is enough!
Straights in Jamaica aren’t worth the spit of land they live on. Today’s Jamaica is a horror story of filthy gangs and drugs, kidnappings and deaths.
As there are NO members of the Jamaican Government who are the slightest bit pro-gay, or even interested in rooting out corruption amongst themselves, there is no reason why any outsider should spend a single minute in Jamaica.
So please, brothers and sisters, DO NOT travel to Jamaica and risk death just to make a point. Your friends and family back in your own countries will suffer the most.
In lieu of that, under the Obama Administration’s new policies, if there are LGBT’s in Jamaica who feel persecuted and are afraid, they can now apply for asylum here in the U.S. The population of Jamaica is 2.8 million and the LGBT population is about 50,000. I think we can absorb these people with open arms.
Just say’n s’all.
I am torn by this.
I do NOT want to see the lives of Jamaican GLBT people made HARDER or MORE DANGEROUS.
Yet at the same time, no other method seems to work. And the loss of economic income from abroad – one of the island’s mainstays – might eventually put enough pressure on island officials to put the welfare of ALL their citizens first – and show some backbone.
In short – I think the United States should make EMIGRATION HERE AUTOMATIC for Jamaican GLBT individuals (since they face imminent danger in their homeland) – while at the same time applying MAXIMUM PRESSURE on the economic and political fronts to force Jamaica to act like a civilized country.
Doing nothing but attempt to persuade through words has FAILED – and since the danger already exists without the boycott, I say how much WORSE can tings get?
Sometimes you have to take risks to achieve social change. In fact, if history has taught us nothing else, you ALWAYS take risk to effect social change.
When people are getting murdered, mutilated, and tortured in their homes and at church, that’s as bad as it gets. The harsh reality is there will never be a good time to stand up and fight back, but the boycott is a start.
Way too late to warn against a boycott. Been boycotting already for about ten years. And we will continue until the status quo changes. Good luck to all. A difficult fight ahead.
It’s difficult for us to make this decision, because we do not have to live with outcome. Not in our day to day lives. The Jamaican LGBT population does.
Should we boycott? I’m not sure. It’s not really our call. There is a reason the community in Jamaica has to hide, and by hurting the country we won’t necissarly be helping them. We don’t have to support Jamaica, but we have to understand that there has to be a change from the inside, not a forced change from the outside.
Forcing the country to change will only make the lives of those who have to live there worse. I actually agree with with the Jamaican GLBT groups. We can support them. We can take them in, and try to help them as much as possible, but the fight to change the country is their fight, and we can’t force it. If we do, more people will be hurt, or worse, die.
A better solution would to create an outreach group to help protect those who cannot protect themselves in Jamaican society. That’s all our job can be. To protect. The majority of us are not Jamaican, and we are not living there, and do not have to deal with the anger the country will feel if their economy is hurt. They won’t suddenly change, and become excepting. They will most likely become even more angry and hateful, and that only leads to uneeded and unwanted violence.
It is easy to say that there is going to be a difficult fight ahead to fight, or to stand up, and whatnot, when you are not living in a country such as Jamaica, and instead are living in, quite frankly, much safer conditions in developed nations where the police will actually protect you and the government does actually recognize you (more or less). It is the height of arrogance to assume the right to protest on behalf of another man, when that very act of protest will lead to much more heightened risk for someone other than yourself.
You can not make such a decision based on the possible evil actions of others.
The only way to make such a call is to weigh the possible harm done against the possible positive outcome.
Can the plight of gay Jamaicans get worse than the current persecution, beatings and murders?
What can I best do to bring about a positive impact?
Personally, I’m going with the boycott.
No Red Stripe or Jamaican Rum in my near future. Time to support the Cubans…they’ve been acting more responsibly lately anyways
We had this same argument when we were fighting apartheid in South Africa: that sanctions would only harm the most vulnerable there, and that they would cause backlash, yet, in the end, nearly everyone credits the US Sanctions and those from other nations as being one of the single largest factors in moving that country to ending apartheid.
Institutionalized hatred like that in Jamaica is insidious and terribly difficult to counteract, but I believe that economic sanctions like boycotting are necessary for any change to occur.
Change is never free of cost and I fear there WILL be a terrible cost to GLBT people in Jamaica, but I fear that the cost of not doing it will be even greater and more terrible.
Change has to start somewhere. Boycott!
If we do not boycott, how else are we supposed to send the message that incessant harassment and abuse of the GLBT community is unacceptable? Are we supposed to say, “we don’t agree with how you treat your own citizens” yet still buy their products and visit their island? To do so would make our verbal protests weak and ineffective. I hope that no one is hurt by the boycott, but we can not stop it because the homophobes might lash out at our community- if we do nothing, they win by default. Boycott Jamaica.
As for this whole boycott idea, you all go right along with it. I guess it makes the lot of you feel like big boys. Something tells me not that many “gay dollars” are going there when you look at the big picture anyway, so you keep on thinking that you are hurting Jamaica by withholding your wallets. Chances are that you aren’t, but hey if it allows you to sleep at night and feel as though you people have accomplished something, then go on ahead.
And for the record, don’t act so high and mighty as to presume that you are doing this boycott for the gay people that are in Jamaica. In reality, most of you don’t really give a damn. And stop acting as though most of you have actually been hurt while there if most of you have been there. Do you live there? Do you frequent there often (and I’m not talking about your comfortable tourist areas). But it sure is easy enough for the majority of you to pass judgment and proclaim action for the safety and security of not living there.
Jamaica is the filthy armpit of the Caribbean. It is a very dangerous place to visit. And while you’re boycotting, please keep Hawaii out of your plans. We can’t even pass a Civil Union bill here. Expensive? You bet. Visit San Francisco or Boston.
This is basically the hostage telling us not to attack the kidnapper. You cannot make a decision based on that. The boycott must go ahead.
Screw Jamaica. You couldn’t pay me to go there never mind pay. UGH – dirty hair pot smokers. Keep your RUM – without Coke it sucks anyway. Their music – pot head crap.
I think we should go even further. I think we should boycott cruise lines that stop in Jamaica until they take this island off of their schedules. LGBT cruisers should not be subjected to this danger! Write to Carnival! (Royal Carribean, Princess, Carnival, Holland America)