November 22nd, 2009
 

365 Gay: News

Indonesia’s Aceh to allow public lashings for gays


(Indonesia) Lawmakers in a devoutly Muslim Indonesian province voted unanimously that adulterers can be sentenced to death by stoning, just months after voters overwhelmingly chose to throw conservative Islamic parties out of power.

With only weeks to go before a new government led by a moderate party takes over in Aceh province, hard-liners still in control of the regional parliament pushed through legislation Monday to impose steep punishments for adultery and homosexuality.

The chairman of the 69-seat house asked if the bill could be passed into law and members answered in unison: “Yes, it can.” Some members of the moderate Democrat Party, which will lead the incoming government, voiced reservations, but none of them voted against the bill.

It also imposes severe prison terms for other behavior considered morally unacceptable, including homosexuality, which will be punishable by public lashings and more than eight years in prison.

Human rights groups said the law violates international treaties signed by Indonesia. The province’s deputy governor also opposed the legislation, saying it needed more careful consideration because it imposes a new form of capital punishment.

The Aceh Party is also believed to have a less strict interpretation of Islamic law, or Shariah, and some activists expressed hope that once in power, they would amend or tone down the law. Others were considering contesting the bill in court in the capital, Jakarta.

Aceh, where Islam first arrived in Indonesia from Saudi Arabia centuries ago, enjoys semiautonomy from the central government. A long-running Islamic insurgency in the province ended in 2005 in the wake of the Indian Ocean tsunami that killed 130,000 there.

A version of Shariah that was introduced in Aceh in 2001 already bans gambling and drinking alcohol, and makes it compulsory for women to wear headscarves. Dozens of public canings have been carried out by the local Shariah police against violators of that law.

The majority of Indonesia’s nearly 200 million Muslims practice a moderate form of the faith, and surveys suggest they do not support such hardline interpretations of the Quran, the Muslim holy book.

Stoning is legally sanctioned in varying forms in Afghanistan, Iran, Pakistan, Sudan, Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates and parts of Nigeria. Illegal stonings have also been reported in recent years in Iraq and Somalia. But its use is a point of contention among Islamic scholars.

The new Indonesian law also imposes tough sentences and fines, to be paid in kilograms of gold, for rape and pedophilia, but the most hotly disputed article was on adultery and states that offenders can be punished by a minimum of 100 lashings and a maximum of stoning to death.

The bill violates national and international treaties signed by Indonesia protecting the rights of minorities and women, said a gay rights activist in Aceh who requested anonymity because he feared for his safety.

“It’s discriminatory, and it’s saddening, but we are quite sure members of civil society who are concerned with human rights will not sit by silently,” the activist said, adding that he hopes the new moderate leadership in the province will overturn the law after taking power next month.

Aceh Vice Governor Muhamad Nazar said that even though his office opposed the clause on stoning to death it has no legal power to block it. “Whatever law is passed we have to enforce it,” he said.


Login or Register to comment.

or Login with Facebook:

  • Drewski Said: September 20th, 2009 at 12:37 am
    • @ng13–Moderate Muslims? I work with several. Psychiatrists, mostly from Bangladesh but some from India too. There were those in my high school. There are those who live in my city who are busy with work and families, as opposed to blowing up synagogues and sending money to al-Qaeda. That said, please give me your explanation for people like Strom Thurmond, Tim McVeigh, Jesse Helms, Oliver North, Glen Beck and other representatives of Christian America.

      Should I mention that the country with the most striking separation of secular and religious power is Turkey, which is at least 97% Muslim? Should I mention that Iranians are inclined to not trust the US and the UK because of a century of intervention in their domestic politics–how would you feel if Iranian cash threw a US election? Angry? Yeah, well, so do they. Do you have the wits to identify the many major schisms in Christianity, versus the single primary split in Islam (which wouldn’t even exist in Christianity, because the Council of Nicea imposed a greater uniformity on early Christianity than any force at a comparable point in Islamic history)? Can you even identify how Christianity forced itself out as a dominant political force in France, Quebec, and Spain? Would you be surprised to know that Palestinians, Iranians and Iraqis as respective groups DO NOT have long histories of extreme religiosity, to the point that their current identification with a militant Islam is largely the manipulated product of disastrous American involvement? We created a lot of the mess; what we didn’t create ourselves, we very often enabled.

      In the UK, Islam is beginning to evolve as another tradition, but a very homegrown tradition rooted in the culture and not the bogeyman some “christian” wingnut wants to paint it as. Same is true in Canada.

      I’m atheist. My primary concern about religion–ANY religion–is that it stays away from my or anybody else’s genitals or brain. I have as many issues with ignorant Christians (I’ll let the example of Northern Ireland stand here) as I do with ignorant Muslims (too many examples to list), ignorant Shintos (Japan is incredibly racist), ignorant Hindus (BJP–thanks for embedding idiocy in Indian politics), and ignorant Jews (I’ll be happy when the wingnut “settlers” give up their US and Canadian passports and STAND ON THEIR OWN). That’s just a start. Nobody gets a pass if they have dirty hands, and we all do. You’re not offering anything as a constructive solution, and a constructive solution at this point involves religion being subordinated to a civil state. Is that what you want, or just some boorish and ignorant finger-pointing? I don’t need to impose atheism on believers–if my influence leads them away from religion, that’s what they were ready for anyway, but it’s not for me to make that choice for somebody else. Not if I stand by my espoused beliefs.

  • michaelandfred Said: September 19th, 2009 at 10:21 am
    • All kinds of crazy….. Funny how they have no problem using all the modern technological advances mankind has created over the years but insist that behavior stays in the stone ages. If they want to live in an age depicted in the oldest religious texts they should live their whole lives like that. I’m pretty sure Mohammad never drover a car, used a stove or refrigerator, telephone, come on you pure of heart and mind, put your creature comforts where your religion is…… But of course, THAT would be crazy…..

  • Charlie Brennan Said: September 19th, 2009 at 9:14 am
    • Cutting aid will only cause terrible suffering to all the people regardless of whether they support this appalling interpretation of religious law. Children and women get hit hardest by poverty: precisely the people who are least responsible for these savage penalties. And remember that at least 6% of the people in Aceh, as everywhere else ARE homosexual too.

  • ng13 Said: September 17th, 2009 at 4:02 pm
    • Tells you so much about “moderate” muslims ( or religionists for that matter.)

  • Morgan Said: September 17th, 2009 at 7:58 am
    • American pop culture has people worldwide aping us Americans listening to ugly music and wearing ugly clothes.

  • Drewski Said: September 16th, 2009 at 11:57 pm
    • It doesn’t help that we just spent eight years with an administration which demonized Islam and muslims at every turn, but this is yet another example of the US and other Western countries failing to reshape Islam. There isn’t much room for true religious scholarship in most Muslim-majority countries. There’s never been an equivalent of the Reformation. We in the US, especially, have allowed illiterate mountain tribesmen to redefine Islam in their image. We conveniently forget that it was those Muslims who preserved classical texts and then shared our Greco-Roman heritage with us…while we of European descent still called lice “pearls of God.” American pop culture goes worldwide. American-based religious activity has had a global impact (half of South Korea is Christian, due in no small part to US missionaries; Protestants now account for as much as a quarter of the population in Central America, again because of US missionaries). Christianity was imported to Europe. Why can’t we in North America and Europe reshape Islam in an image that fits our cultures?

  • sharpjwe Said: September 16th, 2009 at 8:51 pm
    • our aid money goes to finace these intolerant people .
      stop all aid now and let their god treat them as they wish
      gods and religions are man made
      to control and opress the minorities
      another bloody proof of the babary of Islam teachings.

  • Wayne M. Said: September 16th, 2009 at 8:38 pm
    • This is one of many countries with whom we continue to carry on trade, tourism and cultural relations. Do we ever learn?! If we believe in freedom, democracy and human rights, we need to stop having relationships with those countries and governments where human rights of women and LGBT people continue to be violated with impunity.

  • secrity Said: September 16th, 2009 at 7:28 pm
    • This is just ONE MORE example of religious homophobia.

  • Juan Costa Rivera Said: September 16th, 2009 at 7:02 pm
    • Sometimes I just can’t get these people… What bothers me the most is that people like that, do live among us…

  • Ladycop Said: September 16th, 2009 at 6:54 pm
    • I have the agree with Mike on this…When I read this I had to ask myself how many LGBT people came to their aid during the tsunami…To me religion has caused more harm than good…People are poisoned and are to blind to see that perhaps text/laws that were written in biblical times DO NOT MAKE SENSE. Being cruel to another human being is just plain discussing, it’s not logical…these people who want to pass those laws are so ignorant it makes me sick. I hope Karma does exists…

  • Randy LaBolle Said: September 16th, 2009 at 4:12 pm
    • “whatever law is passed we shall have to enforce it” hmmm sounds familiar to something I just heard from our own administration in defense of anti-gay legislation….

  • rogerma Said: September 16th, 2009 at 3:56 pm
    • We need to enlist the help of progressive groups & governments internationally and to help ascertain what is the best way we can assist those in danger. We need to know up-to-date legal status of GLBT people in every country, so we, and our supporters are aware of what’s going on, and if there’s anything that can be done to help. And to world travelers, whether we vacation there, or not.

  • matt87 Said: September 16th, 2009 at 1:29 pm
    • Barbarians…

      I take it they know no better.

  • Mike W, South Range WI Said: September 16th, 2009 at 1:11 pm
    • This was the area devastated by the December 2004 earthquake and subsequent tsunami. What a slap in the face to the GLBT people across the world who sent aid to that region. I also remember that while many tourists in the area evacuated right afterward, some of them chose to stay behind and help with the rescue and recovery efforts. I wonder how many of those heroic people were GLBT?

 
Login

Register
Lost your password?


or Login with Facebook