Hawaii Senate fails to bring vote on civil unions
03.26.2009 8:49am EDT
The Hawaii Senate rejected an effort Wednesday to force a vote on same-sex civil unions, essentially killing the measure, even though a majority had indicated it supports the unions.
The vote on the legislative maneuver fell three short of the nine required for a full Senate vote. About 18 of the 25 senators had indicated they support civil unions, but they lacked the political willpower to go against Senate President Colleen Hanabusa and most of her leadership team, which opposed the effort.Hanabusa has supported civil unions but said she didn’t want to override the normal lawmaking process by lifting the bill from its committee, where it had stalled on a tie vote.
Senate Judiciary Chairman Brian Taniguchi said there was still hope that the bill could be amended and revived, but that probably wouldn’t happen until next year.
Dennis Arakaki, executive director of the Hawaii Family Forum, applauded the result.
“It affirms the will of the people,” he said. “Senators realized the impact of this issue. They may have been looking for rationale of how they could either avoid the issue or put it to bed.”
Opponents had argued that same-sex civil unions were the same as gay marriage.
Only two states, Massachusetts and Connecticut, allow gay marriage. The Vermont Senate passed a gay marriage bill last week, but Republican Gov. Jim Douglas said Wednesday he would veto it if it lands on his desk.
Nearly 70 percent of Hawaii voters approved a constitutional amendment in 1998 granting the state Legislature the power to reserve marriage for couples of one man and one woman, which it did.




I live on Maui and our GAY east county (closeted)lawmaker, J. Kalani English didn’t even show up to vote. What a jerk. Its one thing to hide in a closet like a coward, but another thing entirely to actually sabatoge the efforts of those who want equality for themselves and other gays. We voted for you because we wanted to see another gay man do well, but you haven’t done ANYTHING Senator ENGLISH. You should be ashamed. Consider yourself OUTTED! And if you’d like to dispute my claims I’d be happy to discuss it publicly(along with some other BEACH buddies).
STAY AWAY IF YOU’RE GAY! Boycott the Islands, there are other warm and gay friendly places to go to.
Michael, the “Aloha Spirit” is an invention of the Hawaii visitors bureau.
It will never happen here. Get real. STAY AWAY IF YOU’RE GAY, avoid Hawaii, there are other warm beautiful and gay friendly places for a vacation. Time for a gay boycott.
Dennis Arakaki, executive director of the Hawaii Family Forum, applauded the result. “It affirms the will of the people,” he said.
:S From a vote that’s eleven years old…I’m pretty sure things change.
Dennis Arakaki, executive director of the Hawaii Family Forum, applauded the result. “It affirms the will of the people,” he said.
Really? Aren’t gays people?
Once again hate and fear won out!
The Aloha spirit is DEAD in my state!
Missy Dennis Arakaki:
Was it a good thing when it was the will of the people to have segregation, or slavery, or not allowing women to vote ?
You lack compassion. All that most Gay people want is to be able to take care of their loved ones in time of crisis and be treated fairly. Sorry this threatens your narrow, uneducated world view.
Tom in Long Beach
‘ they lacked the political willpower’
what a bunch of pansies