Former Catholic archbishop of Milwaukee comes out
05.12.2009 8:39am EDT
(New York City) A Roman Catholic archbishop who resigned in 2002 over a sex and financial scandal involving a man describes his struggles with being gay in an upcoming memoir about his decades serving the church.
Archbishop Rembert Weakland, former head of the Milwaukee archdiocese, said in an interview Monday that he wrote about his sexual orientation because he wanted to be candid about “how this came to life in my own self, how I suppressed it, how it resurrected again.”Called “A Pilgrim in a Pilgrim Church: Memoirs of a Catholic Archbishop,” the book is set to be released in June.
“I was very careful and concerned that the book not become a Jerry Springer, to satisfy people’s prurient curiosity or anything of this sort,” Weakland told The Associated Press. “At the same time, I tried to be as honest as I can.”
Weakland stepped down soon after Paul Marcoux, a former Marquette University theology student, revealed in May 2002 that he was paid $450,000 to settle a sexual assault claim he made against the archbishop more than two decades earlier. The money came from the archdiocese.
Marcoux went public at the height of anger over the clergy sex abuse crisis, when Catholics and others were demanding that dioceses reveal the extent of molestation by clergy and how much had been confidentially spent to settle claims.
Weakland denied ever assaulting anyone. He apologized for concealing the payment. The Vatican says that men with “deep-seated” attraction to other men should not be ordained.
In an August 1980 letter that was obtained by the Milwaukee Journal-Sentinel, Weakland said he was in emotional turmoil over Marcoux and that he had “come back to the importance of celibacy in my life.” He signed the letter, “I love you.”
The revelations rocked the Milwaukee archdiocese, which Weakland had led since 1977. He was a hero for liberal Catholics nationwide because of his work on social justice and other issues.
The archbishop, now 82, said he seriously considered the potential pain for the archdiocese of renewing attention to the scandal and thought about waiting “until I was dead” to have it published. But he decided to move ahead with the project.
“What I felt was that people who loved me as bishop here, when they read the book will continue to love me. The people who found it difficult, I hope will be helped a little bit by the book,” he said.
In a sign of the deep emotions still surrounding Weakland and his departure, the Archdiocese of Milwaukee has released a public statement alerting local Catholics to the upcoming book.
“Some people will be angry about the book, others will support it,” the archdiocese said.
Weakland also writes about his failures to stop sexually abusive priests. In a videotaped deposition released last November, Weakland admitted returning guilty priests to active ministry without alerting parishioners or police.
“Any deposition is just a part of a whole picture and that picture has not been painted yet. And anybody can take out of that any sentence they want,” Weakland said in the interview.
“I try to deal with this, I hope in an honest way, admitting my weaknesses in not being able to see this earlier, but at the same time doing what I could confront it.”
Advocates for abuse victims said that Weakland’s cover-up of his own sexual activity was part of a pattern of secrecy that included concealing the criminal behavior of child molesters.
Weakland, a Benedictine monk, served in Rome as leader of the International Benedictine Confederation and also worked on a liturgy commission for the Second Vatican Council, which made reforms in the 1960s meant to modernize the church.
Weakland said he wrote in the memoir that he was unprepared for “how lonely it is” to be a bishop and how difficult it can be to get the “feedback and support you need.”
U.S. Catholics have long debated whether the priesthood had become a predominantly gay vocation. Estimates vary from 25 percent to 50 percent, according to a review of research on the issue by the Rev. Donald Cozzens, author of “The Changing Face of the Priesthood.”
Weakland said Christians needed to speak more openly about gays in the priesthood without the “hysteria” that often characterizes the debate.
The archbishop has been living in a retirement community near the Milwaukee archdiocese and plans to move to St. Mary’s Abbey in Morristown, N.J., this summer. He said he was not bitter about how the scandal had eclipsed his decades of work in the church.
“I refused to let myself become a victim and refused to let myself become angry,” he said. “I want to take responsibility but I want to move on.”





Oh, the stupid Catholic Church and their turmoil over their poor gay personnel. Just can’t seem to get their act together about who and what they are before hiding behind the church. When will it ever end.
Archbishop Rembert Weakland, Welcome to NJ. Please support gay marriage when your here!
Good for him. In contact with gay former military Chaplains… pre DADT luckily. But still hard on them as well.
Honesty is ALWAYS the best policy. (Hear that Dick Cheney)
Wonder what lame excuse Obama will use now to delay repealing DADT.
My parents were married in a Catholic church in Milwaukee in 1969. They recently celebrated their 40th wedding anniversary in a legal, now same-sex marriage. My parent transitioned from male to female more than 25 years ago and my folks chose to keep their marriage intact. People tell me and my parents daily how our nontraditional family is evil and despicable. It’s so freaking awesome hearing that from people who constantly judge us, despite being told not to judge others. I honor my parents in accordance with the 10 commandments.
My folks committed to “Let No One Rend Asunder” their wedding vows in front their god, family and friends. Let’s hope Weakland’s coming out will affect positive change within both the Catholic and LGBT communities.
What gays both outside and inside the oppressive Catholic church don’t need is another “soul searching” introspective autobiography by an “I’m gay” priest.
What all of us need is a high ranking Catholic prelate– even if retired– taking the lead in condemning hateful antigay dogma and discrimination. Throw in the BS against women, too.
The man who followed Weakland to Milwaukee, Timothy Dolan, is now archbigot of New York, challenging marriage equality in that state. Why not begin by attacking him, and supporting civil marriage for same sex couples, Wembert?
The decision by Archbishop Weakland of Milwaukee to come out of the closet and fully admit his struggles with homosexuality raises some very important issues.
First: There is no excuse for covering up pedophilia, which is a crime of sexual assault and abusing power to gain the sexual favours of minors. It is also a crime to cover up a serious criminal act and this is exactly what Roman Catholic Bishops and Archbishops did when they transferred priests involved in pedophilia from one parish to another rather than report the crime to responsible legal authorities. As a Gay man, I do not want our legitimate fight for equality to be confused with sexual abuse of children and youth. Legal authorities need to prosecute any and all Roman Catholic authorities involved in any cover-up of pedophilia by priests.
Second: It is all fine and nice for Archbishop Weakland to publish his memoirs and tell about his struggle with his sexual orientation. However, what is he going to do to push his church to consider current scientific and psychological evidence on homosexuality and reverse its homophobic policies of discrimination that is causing change? What is he going to do to push his church to reverse its policies on priestly celibacy that has turned many good men into sexual time bombs as they try without success to hide and deny their sexuality and sexual orientation?
Third: Is Pope Ratzinger and the Roman Catholic Church going to try and suppress Archbishop Weakland’s story or face the fact that their policies and doctrines are causing harm? Sadly, evidence already shows it is more likely to do the former. Tragically, this causes great harm to both LGBT people and to the Christian faith.
Brave man. Expose the hypocrisy. Only when the current upper level bigots are gone to God, or H…, will the church come to its senses.
and if you stay in the church, it is up to you, whoever you are, to speak for the good priests who believe gay people are also part of God’s creation, but dare not speak out, lest their eviction notice arrives from the Vatican.
The same eviction notice the churches didn’t send to all those priests who abused children, male (most available), and female also.
Laurie said “My parent transitioned from male to female more than 25 years ago and my folks chose to keep their marriage intact. ”
I actually met two women who had exactly the same situation.
Love conquers all, and it will ultimately conquer the arrogant, ignorant, hatefull so called christians and other phobes.
Keep at making this happen
The fact that he covered for those accursed pedophiles is unforgivable. Adding in his relationship with a male theology student from Marquette University, he sure is one of the worst types of gays. His reward? Free housing in retirement community near the Milwaukee archdiocese. I’ll definitely read his memoirs and thus use it as a reminder of not making poor choices like him.