California Cliffhanger, Florida, Arizona, Arkansas Voters OK Anti-Gay Ballot Measures
11.05.2008 12:31am EST
Updated November 5, 2008 -8:30 am EST
(Washington) An amendment to the California constitution to overturn the state Supreme Court ruling granting gay and lesbian couples the right to marry appeared headed for victory Wednesday morning, but opponents are yet not willing to concede defeat.
Results from more than 90 percent of precincts throughout California show the proposed amendment with a slim two percent lead – 52 to 48 percent.
While the initiative’s supporters were celebrating, opponents insisted it was premature to concede. Late absentee and provisional ballots meant as many as 3 million ballots were left to be counted after all precinct votes were tallied.
It is the first time such a vote has taken place in state where gay unions are legal.
A study by the Williams Institute at UCLA School of Law indicated that by Election Day 2008, approximately18,000 same-sex couples had married in California.
Exit polls reported by CNN show that while a slim majority of white voters said they rejected the amendment, an equally slim majority of African American and Hispanic voters said they had voted for the amendment.
The battle for and against the measure, known as Proposition 8, cost more than $67 million, making it one of the most expensive ballot campaigns in history. Much of the money on both sides came from outside California.
The highly charged campaign resulted in a number of incidents throughout California.
Last week, a cyber attack brought down the “No on Prop 8″campaign Web site. The FBI and Secret Service are investigating.
In Fresno, police are investigating death threats against two local supporters of Proposition 8 – Mayor Alan Autry and Pastor Jim Franklin of the Cornerstone Church.
In Torrance, a man has been charged with a felony hate crime assault for allegedly using an anti-gay marriage “Yes on Prop. 8″ lawn sign to attack a gay man wearing a “No on 8″button.
In Bakersfield, a local leader of the campaign for the ballot measure was videotaped at a pro-gay marriage rally kicking and punching a protester. The protester, who had been heckling him, declined to press charges.
In Roseville, three young people were arrested on suspicion of stealing “Yes on 8″ signs from several front yards.
Florida
In Florida, the ballot measure amends the state constitution to limit marriage to opposite sex couples and ban civil unions.
The amendment also could be used to deny partner benefits to unmarried couples who live together.
The amendment says, “Inasmuch as marriage is the legal union of only one man and one woman, no other legal union that is treated as marriage or the substantial equivalent thereof shall be valid or recognized.”
Constitutional amendments in Florida require a 60 percent majority. The marriage amendment won with 62 percent of the vote. Thirty-eight percent were opposed.
Florida already had a law restricting marriage to opposite-sex couples, but supporters of the amendment say the law could be overturned in court.
Arizona
In Arizona, where a simple majority is needed to amend the state constitution, 56 percent of voters approved limiting marriage to opposite-sex couples.
It was the second time Arizona voters were asked to change the state’s constitution to define marriage as a union between one man and one woman.
Voters rejected a similar state constitutional amendment in 2006. That measure would have also stopped the state from recognizing civil unions of same-sex couples.
Arizona law already prohibits same-sex marriages. Supporters say the amendment will “protect the sanctity of families” by preventing judges from overturning the 1996 state law.
Arkansas
Arkansas, which already has a constitutional amendment banning same-sex marriage, now will limit adoptions and foster care of children to people who are legally married.
The ballot measure passed Tuesday by a wide margin – 57-43 percent.
The measure grew out of a state Supreme Court ruling last year that overturned a Child Welfare Agency Review Board policy that banned gay people from serving as foster parents.
In its unanimous ruling, the court said that “the driving force behind adoption of the regulations was not to promote the health, safety and welfare of foster children but rather based upon the board’s views of morality and its bias against homosexuals.”
The Arkansas Family Council – the same group that spearheaded Arkansas’ constitutional ban on same-sex marriage – collected enough signatures to place the adoption referendum before voters.
Connecticut
In Connecticut, a potential anti-gay measure was also on the ballot. Connecticut voters turned down a call for state constitutional convention.
Under the state constitution, the question automatically goes on the ballot only every 20 years.
Earlier this year, the state Supreme Court ruled that Connecticut’s civil unions law failed to provide equality. The first same-sex marriages in the state are slated to begin Nov. 12.
By chance, the automatic ballot question came up this year, raising fears that if voters agreed to a constitutional convention it would have been used to ban gay marriage.
The Family Institute of Connecticut had gone on record calling for a constitutional amendment banning same-sex marriage.




Personally I feel like we need a national Stonewall. It is absolutely ridiculous that we should be subjected to the whims of a group of people that will never have to go through anything like what we suffer through. I’m most disappointed in the apparent wide-spread support from the African-American community. How many times have the GLBT community stood up for equality based on race? Yet when the time comes to help us out suddenly it’s amoral? I never want to hear another black person bemoan their situation because they are black; it is obvious that Gay is the new national punching bag.
Wow! well done America
I can’t believe CA cares more about farm animals then they care more about me. Florida is disgusting! Pregnant pigs have constitutional protection in the Sunshine State, but I’m nothing in the eyes of those voters. How can I be proud of a country that’s so ashamed of me?
According to latest from CNN: A ballot initiative to ban gay marriage in California appears headed for a narrow defeat, exit polls showed.
Voters in California, Arizona and Florida weigh in on constitutional bans on same-sex marriage.
Proposition Eight, which would eliminate the right of same-sex couples to marry in California, was losing — 53 percent to 47 percent, according to the polling.
A friend in the White House…Sure. One who is on record, along with his Vice President, as being against gay marriage.
Like most other politicians, Mr. Obama will not risk his political neck to help gays and lesbians.
Well, in AZ we expected the worst for gay marriage as the opposition had all the money. At least the amendment defined marriage in strictly heterosexist terms and left domestic partnerships out of the picture, as it was included in the 2006 election. If Republicans continue this assault on our rights, then I support southern AZ’s succession from the evil northern half of the state where the extreme right wing controls this state. Let’s hear it for the progressive half of AZ where I live in Tucson. For everyone else, let’s regroup and work for solid domestic partnerships.
I will certainly be checking where my oranges come from. Nothing from Florida (or any state with a similarly bigoted constitution) will be welcome in my home.
looks like our world just got a bit smaller. Massachusettes, anyone?
We’re canceling our spring break trip to Florida. I will not spend another dime there.
If California passed the anti-gay amendment, Obama would mean nothing to us, the gays and lesbians.
This has to go to the Supreme Court in DC. This kind of blatant descrimination has got to stop. Where do I send my check?
SUCK IT UP! WE FINALLY HAVE A FRIEND IN THE WHITE HOUSE!! They won this battle, but we will TOTALLY win the WAR!!
My own sister voted against me, so listen to me when I say we will EFFIN WIN!
We are under attack. These people are truly evil.
this is hurtful to me because as a little girl all i ever wanted was to get married and little by little this is being torn from me state by state by these inhumane amendments and bans. how would they feel if we were the ones who decided if they were allowed to marry or adopt children. but that is never brought into question because of a technical definition of marriage. marriage should be based on love and nothing else and parenting should be based also on love and that is the just of it
Prop 8 is going to pass and I’m am so upset. This is CA for God’s sake. We just got married in Sept. and the bigots are going to take that away from us. There has got to be an uprising in the gay community to combat this divisive measure. It is unfair, unjust, and illegal.
This is not the end will are going to continue fighting