November 9th, 2009
 

365 Gay: News

Aviator hopes gay ban will end in time for him


(Boise, Idaho) Barack Obama’s campaign promise to scrap the military’s “don’t ask, don’t tell” policy gave Lt. Col. Victor Fehrenbach hope. Now the aviator is wondering if the president will deliver in time to save his 18-year Air Force career.

The winner of nine air medals for distinguished service in flight, including one for heroism the night U.S. forces captured Baghdad International Airport in 2003, Fehrenbach is in the process of getting kicked out of the military a year after an acquaintance told his bosses he was gay.

He thought he could hang on until the government eliminated the military’s policy forcing gays and lesbians to keep their sexual orientation secret, but now he isn’t so sure.

Obama “was someone who had experienced discrimination firsthand and that’s why I had a lot of faith,” Fehrenbach said. “I thought, OK I can fight this, and maybe by January Obama could be inaugurated and this won’t matter.

“That hasn’t happened.”

The Servicemembers Legal Defense Network, an advocacy group seeking equal treatment of gays in the military, estimates that more than 200 service members have been discharged under “don’t ask, don’t tell” since Obama was sworn into office.

The White House insists officials are working to overturn the policy, but when that will happen is unclear. The reassurances mean little to Fehrenbach, who has flown on missions in Afghanistan and Iraq and is about to lose the only way of life he’s ever known just two years before he would be eligible to retire.

Fehrenbach, 39, is the son of an Air Force veterans – his father was a lieutenant colonel who died when he was 9 and his mother is a former military nurse who lives in Ohio. Last week he told his relatives he is gay, was being discharged from the Air Force and was going on national television to talk about it.

“Now, I’m not hiding anything,” said Fehrenbach, who has appeared on Rachel Maddow’s MSNBC’s talk show and remains on active duty at the Mountain Home Air Force Base in the Idaho desert, about 60 miles southeast from Boise. “For 18 years, I played by the rules and I kept my private life private.”

Most of the estimated 13,000 service members discharged under “don’t ask, don’t tell” since the law was enacted in 1993 have opted to leave quietly and close the final chapter of their military careers in private. Groups calling for the repeal of the ban, however, say Fehrenbach is among a growing number who are going public with a newfound sense of urgency.

In September, Fehrenbach had decided to accept an honorable discharge and waive his right to a military hearing, where he would have to lie about being gay in order to stay in the Air Force. He refused.

“I just wanted this to go away, I didn’t tell anyone, I didn’t want anyone to know,” Fehrenbach said.

He quickly changed his mind and with encouragement from five close friends, one a fellow service member, he rescinded the waiver and tried to stall the hearing that would determine his military fate.

The military hearing was delayed until April, when Fehrenbach was told he had been recommended for an honorable discharge. The process could take about five months to complete because of his record and rank, he said; he doesn’t know whether he’ll be able stay in the Air Force if “don’t ask, don’t tell” is repealed before then.

“I will fight this in uniform and I’ll fight it without,” Fehrenbach said. “I swore an oath to defend and support the Constitution, I’m going to speak out and fight this until the law is repealed because it is not constitutional.”

He said “don’t ask, don’t tell” denies American service members their constitutional right to privacy, due process and equal protection, and forces them to lie about who they are when honesty is part of the code they serve under.

The Servicemembers Legal Defense Network, which is representing Fehrenbach while he explores his legal options, wants Obama to begin working with Congress to repeal the law.

“He said he was going to fix it,” said Aubrey Sarvis, the group’s executive director. “We need a plan and a timeline from the White House on how we’re going to get this done.”

A bill that would allow gays to serve openly has been introduced in Congress.

Obama’s top advisers want the president to move more slowly in overturning the policy than many gay-rights activists would like, citing other priorities including the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan. “We have a lot on our plate right now,” retired Marine Gen. James Jones, the White House’s national security adviser, said this month.

On the other side of the debate, the Michigan-based Center for Military Readiness gathered signatures earlier this year from more than 1,000 retired military officers urging the president and Congress to keep the ban.

“It’s really not fair to the women and men of our armed forces to be part of this social experiment,” said center president Elaine Donnelly. “Military life is difficult enough without having this additional burden. This is harmful to good order and discipline and morale.”

In the midst of debate over whether gays should be allowed to serve without fear of retribution if their sexual orientation is disclosed by them, or someone else, a family rooted in military tradition is mourning the loss of a career.

Fehrenbach’s family supports his decision to speak out and try to get the ban repealed, said his sister, Angie Trumbauer, a 47-year-old Air Force veteran who lives in Ohio.

She said she wasn’t surprised when her never-married brother told her he was gay, but when she realized he would not retire with full military honors, it was almost like there was a death in the family.

“This is the only thing he’s ever known in life,” Trumbauer said. “it’s all he’s ever wanted to do.”


Login or Register to comment.

or Login with Facebook:

  • JoeyinCT Said: May 29th, 2009 at 9:52 am
    • America: Land of the Corrupt.

      “We’ll take your tax dollars, but deny you your equal protections and civil rights as we chose. But hey, thanks for playing!”

      Bullshit!

  • chuck Said: May 29th, 2009 at 10:21 am
    • Hey, Obama!

      Is it the right time yet?

      No? How about now?

      -c

  • Aaron F. Said: May 29th, 2009 at 10:31 am
    • Tragic. Stories like these should be trumpeted from every major news outlet, and should inspire the shame in President Obama that his backpedaling has engendered.

  • Brittany Said: May 29th, 2009 at 10:49 am
    • Wow! I am stationed in Fort Carson, Colorado and we just had two soldiers get in trouble for child pornography and another soldier stabbed his girlfriend! They are NOT and I repeat NOT getting discharged…. now someone like myself who is a lesbian could and has gotten threated to get discharged for being gay! I didn’t even come out and they were trying to discharge me b/c they “assumed” I was gay. I am an Iraqi veteran…. fought for my country and being threatened to get kicked out b/c I like someone of the same sex is NON SENSE! We can get married in some states where WE have duty stations…where is the justice? Freedom of state? Hmm… this is what I call …. BULL! And I voted for Obama

  • Todd Said: May 29th, 2009 at 10:52 am
    • “For 18 years, I played by the rules and I kept my private life private.”

      That wasn’t playing the by the rules. According to the armed forces policy a person serving is to not engage in any homosexual activity, regardless if they are on or off base, even in their private lives.

  • Dan Said: May 29th, 2009 at 11:13 am
    • Obama simply lied… What the big deal?

  • R & R Said: May 29th, 2009 at 11:27 am
    • Would it be rude and inappropiate to call Elain Donnelly a vicious [JERK]?

  • ALAN Said: May 29th, 2009 at 11:27 am
    • It is too bad that the armed services aren’t the Roman Catholic priesthood.
      Where they just move you to another parish (duty station) when you have had any form of sex (homosexual,pedophilia or whatever).

      I hope that Obama will put a stop to DADT. When you have priorities like two wars — do you really want to kick out people that you can’t really afford to?

  • R & R Said: May 29th, 2009 at 11:40 am
    • I think the GLBT community can pretty well forget about Obama doing anything about DADT or DOMA. I would not be in his political interest to upset the praise jesus crowd. He is just as two faced as Bush and Clinton. Remember, he said that he believes marriage should be between a hole and a pole. That just about says it all.

  • Howard Said: May 29th, 2009 at 11:45 am
    • How very sad. Another brave American soldier, who wants to do the right thing, gets kicked to the curb. President Obama, when will this end?

  • JJ in Chicago Said: May 29th, 2009 at 11:47 am
    • I wish Lt. Col. Fehrenbach the best.

      Important note, rarely mentioned: Elaine Donnelly, so-called “President” of Center for Military readiness, is NOT an expert in military readiness.

      She is a self-appointed, homophobic hack who is an opportunist that injects herself in a terrible policy that is destroying careers and costing American taxpayers millions. (She’s no different that nutcases like Paul Cameron or Peter LaBarbera).

      This woman has no credibility and props herself up by pandering to homophobic insecurities and prejudices in people.

      Disregard anything Elaine Donnelly says.

  • Darryl in Australia Said: May 29th, 2009 at 12:14 pm
    • I certainly don’t know the finer points of the DADT policy, and maybe I am looking at this too simply but it appears from the story that Lt. Col. Victor Fehrenbach did not initially breach the policy:
      “after an acquaintance told his bosses he was gay” – Fehrenbach did “not tell”, and:
      “a military hearing, where he would have to lie about being gay in order to stay in the Air Force” implies that the military would ask him during a hearing if he is gay – the policy says they cannot ask.
      He did not tell them, they cannot ask if he is gay – policy not breached.
      I know that this is all theoretical now as Lt. Col. Victor Fehrenbach has gone public with his sexuality.

      “It’s really not fair to the women and men of our armed forces to be part of this social experiment,” said center president Elaine Donnelly. “Military life is difficult enough without having this additional burden. This is harmful to good order and discipline and morale.”
      How on earth does she come up with this garbage – this can be simply refuted by looking at the military of many countries who accept openly gay soldiers and it has no effect at all.

      Every story I read of DADT discharges I just continue to shake my head and wonder if the US will ever actually live up to the constitution that is so proudly quoted but only acted on to serve the interests of the majority.

  • R & R Said: May 29th, 2009 at 12:38 pm
    • Darryl,your’ve hit the nail on the head! I have been asking anyone who if in a position of authority (congressmen, congresswomen, etc) what problems will we experience if DADT is cancelled that the other countries who have gays serving openly don’t have and NO ONE will even address the question. Is the question that difficult to understand or answer? Does it require an advanced degree? What am I missing?

      The same could be applied to permitting gays to marry. In Canada gays serve openly in the military and gays can marry. The last time I checked Canada did not fall off of the planet and the county has not been taken over by rampant sexual deviancy. So what in hell is this country’s problem? Maybe the anti-christ has secretly taken over Canada and we just don’t know it.

      Maybe this has been addressed and the media is merely ignoring it.

      Maybe Obama can answer these questions – or not. Too much on his plate, right?

  • John A. Richardson Said: May 29th, 2009 at 1:51 pm
    • Had enough yet? On December 19, when it became clear that Mr. Obama was going to allow a homophobic pastor to speak at his inaugural, I re-registered from Dem to Independent. That was the shot across the bow that he will do nothing for Gay people, period. We have heard for years from our Rep. Susan Davis that it just “isn’t time, yet.” As a Vietnam Vet (68-72), I am disgusted. No more support for either Dem or Repug(nant) until this is taken care of. I will sit the next election out. No money, no support. This is a disgusting situation. Rachel Maddow exposed the lie that has gone on here on MSNBC. It is truely embarrassing to watch this happen to America. Jesse Ventura said it last night about our elected representatives…they would be taking care of the messes if they weren’t complicit.

  • Robert, NYC Said: May 29th, 2009 at 1:57 pm
    • Now that DADT is now being stalled by the military, if Obama were truly and genuinely interested in repealing it, he could have easily prevented Dan Choi and Victor Fehrenbach from being kicked out as a gesture of good will, at least it would have been an acknowledgement that he is going to keep his campaign promise. But no, he chose to remain silent. When god is in the mix, clearly in Obama’s case, don’t expect miracles or anything for that matter. We were used to get him elected, nothing more and as far as I’m concerned, there is no change as he’d promised, not even in sight.

 
Login

Register
Lost your password?


or Login with Facebook