Messages That Lead to Murder
This week, I attended the Commercial Closet’s Images In Advertising Awards in Manhattan, which honored corporations that produced gay affirming ads. The pro-gay plugs showed genuine progress and highlighted that many leading companies “get it.”
The work of Commercial Closet is vital because images matter and repeated exposure to messages shape our views and create positive change in society. The cleverness and creativity in these ads imparts to millions of people that homosexuality is nothing to be feared and that GLBT people are part of the human family.The awards ceremony was a welcome respite from reality, where there is no shortage of reminders that the world is still a very dangerous place.
In Knoxville, Tennessee, a homophobic loser burst into a Unitarian Church where a children’s play was being performed and unleashed a fusillade of gunfire, killing two people and injuring six. According to police, Jim D. Adkisson, “had targeted the church because of its liberal leanings and his belief that all liberals should be killed because they were ruining the country.”
The New York Times reports that the killer was raised in strict a Christian home and was openly anti-gay. He may have targeted this particular church because his former wife – who he had threatened to shoot and then commit suicide – had occasionally attended. He may also have been agitated by the church’s affirming stand on GLBT equality.
The far right’s dirty little secret is that they depend on the threat of violence to retard the advancement of the GLBT movement. Without the fear of physical attack, the number of people who are out of the closet would quickly multiply. Gay couples would hold hands in every city in the nation. On each block, from San Francisco to San Antonio, gay and lesbian people would be visibly present.
Each day, all but the bravest GLBT people make subtle or even significant adjustments to remain safe. Some dress a little blander in order to blend in. A number of gay men talk a bit deeper so they won’t arouse suspicion. Some lesbians apply make up so they won’t get beaten up. And, most loving couples act like buddies so they won’t get bashed.
We tell ourselves comforting lies, such as “we don’t like public displays of affection,” to justify pushing a partner’s hand away at a romantic moment. But, the reality is, even the most confident and brave among us have something to fear.
Of course, the overwhelming majority of people are not violent and a significant minority of Americans fervently supports GLBT people. What the right wing realizes, however, is it only takes a small number of twisted fanatics to keep GLBT people in check. We rarely know who these lunatics are, as they often keep their hate closeted. But, each gay person knows these hidden ticking time bombs exist and could go off at any moment — shattering our lives.
When Focus on the Family’s James Dobson says that giving gay people the freedom to marry will “destroy the earth” he is encouraging hate crimes. When Oklahoma state legislator Sally Kern says that homosexuality is the “death knell of this country,” she is promoting gay bashing. When Elaine Donnelly told a congressional committee that lifting Don’t Ask/Don’t Tell would let lesbians take pictures of people in the shower she was setting the stage for violence. When Ann Coulter authors, “How to Talk To a Liberal (If You Must),” people like Jim Adkisson may be influenced.
What I find hypocritical is that the Religious Right will take any image it deems gay and claim it “promotes homosexuality.” This even extends to fictional characters such as Tinky Winky and Sponge Bob Square Pants. Yet, these same oversensitive preachers refuse to acknowledge that their mean-spirited sermons might lead to violence.
The extreme right fuels anti-gay ugliness, but it is pervasive all around us. As we applauded the winners of the Commercial Closet awards, two ads that subtract from the dignity of gay people were on the minds of those in attendance. The first was a Nike ad where a basketball star leapt over a defender who had the dunker’s scrotum in his face. The headline was “That Ain’t Right.”
In a second ad for Snickers, a swishy speed walker is attacked by a machine gun wielding Mr. T in a truck who demands the walker “run like a real man.” He fires on the guy until he “corrects” his running style. Thanks to The Human Rights Campaign and the willingness of these companies, both ads were pulled.
We live in a society filled with violently homophobic messages and images, yet the perpetrators — both religious and secular — feign innocence and say they can’t imagine how anti-gay hate crimes occur.




It’s funny how religious extremist who claim to follow Christ want to post the Ten Commandments all over the place, but do everything in their power not to give air time to Christ second commandment (Christ only gave two) to “love your neighbor as you love yourself”, or St. Johns version: “Love your neighbor as Christ has love you”. (Just like Fox News does not give air time to anything the Conservative/Religious Right does not want to hear.) But then again, Christ second commandment assumes that you have the ability to love yourself in the first place.
What gets me: the Conservative Gays who support candidates and other militant extremist who support hate and hate speech against the GLBTQ community, and who also justifies that hate aim toward the GLBTQ community. It’s like they rubber stamp their approval to both the Religious and Conservative Right dogma. What can be alarming about this view point: it does not come from some stereotypical old conservative fossil, but from some one you would expect to see on MTV’s real world, or one of their followers. When we don’t challenge hate full talk in our own community, then we are no better then those who brand us with their contempt. Then again, some people have a hard time loving themselves out of their own closets and fears.
It is interesting, and somewhat ironic, that many times in order to charge someone with a hate crime, it is the words of the offender that is often the determining factor, whether it is the outright use of prejudicial slurs or simply statements of intolerance. The laws themselves acknowledge the spoken word as a vehicle to incite action, yet when these very same actions are committed by social institutions such as organized religion, it is considered freedom of speech, a way of expressing their faith and loving their god. There is a very fine line when it comes to deciding which speech should be restricted in an open society, but many places have also made it clear that you cannot yell FIRE! in a crowded theater if there is, in fact, no fire. Hate speech made by one in a position of trust and/or authority is no different in that their words have very obvious consequences and potential to harm innocent people. The Matt Shepards and Lawrence Kings of the world could attest to that, if they were still alive. Maybe it’s time we started hold those who spout hate speech to the same level of accountability and hopefully they will come to understand that freedom of speech is not only saying what you want, when you want but it also comes with a responsibility that such speech does not potentially harm certain segments of society in general.
I agree with a lot of the sentiments on here, but ultimately it’s the losers who make the decision to commit the violence that are responsible. The environment they find themselves in may influence them, but I mostly blame the bashers for what they do.
Wayne:
You are definitely spot on. I would also ad that preachers like Rod Parsley who openly use militaristic language are very dangerous as well. His youth group “Battle Cry” was in San Francisco some time back and was told by the SF Board of Supervisors that they will not be allowed to have a “rally” in SF next year.
His war-like sermons are unabashedly violent. When it comes to Islam, he has told people point blank that it needs to be “destroyed.” He may backtrack a little by saying that “well, I’m sure there are SOME good Muslims out there,” but he distinctly calls for PEOPLE TO KILL OTHER PEOPLE.
It’s very, very difficult for us to make them stop, but I think of it this way: between now and the time there is no hate speech coming from the pulpit, somebody will be killed.
How many? Who knows? Maybe some time in the future, someone like Jim Adkisson will say, “God speaks through my minister and he told me to do it!”
Thanks Wayne for the good article. The religious right are blatant in their evil teachings that promote violence toward the members of the gay community.
Of course. The closet, enforced by terrorism, is nothing different then the segregation of blacks, enforced by murders and firebombings, and also justified by a perverted use of the Bible.
Great article, Wayne!!!
The Nike and Snickers (Mars Co.) ads were horrifying. The fact that they got on the air at all is disturbing. And Mars is a repeat offender.