Ruby-Sachs: Stacy and Karla

Stacy Beardsley and Karla Thomas met three and a half years ago at a friend’s birthday party. Two months later, they were dating and now, three and half years after that night, they live together in a house in north Chicago with their two black labs Kobi and Maddi (just nine weeks old).
They are like any other couple.
Stacy, a former public school principal, now works to design academic curricula for schools in the city. Karla is a Engineering project manager for an international cosmetics company. At the end of the work day they might meet up with their neighbors to walk the dogs or work on the small yard in front of their home.
Two weeks ago Karla’s entire department was eliminated due to cut costs and now, as a Trinidadian citizen on an H1B visa, she will have to leave the country once her employment terminates. She has only a few months to find a job that is willing to take on the burden and currently heavily publicized stigma of sponsoring a foreign worker on an H1B visa or she will be forced to return to Trinidad alone.
Their story was supposed to go much differently.
If Stacy and Karla were in an opposite-sex relationship they would be married and Stacy could sponsor Karla to remain in the country.
Even if Karla couldn’t find a job right away, she would be allowed to stay in her own house, with her partner while she searched for new employment. Stacy could take on extra hours and support them both. Karla holds an MBA from Northwestern’s Kellogg School of Management, an undergraduate degree in mechanical engineering from the University of Mississippi and ten years of experience, so when the economy stabilized she’d likely find a place to land.
But Illinois doesn’t have marriage for same-sex couples. It doesn’t even have civil unions. And even if it did, the Defense of Marriage Act bars same-sex couples from acquiring the immigration rights that come with any heterosexual marriage.
“If it were a question of her being away for a year, then we could figure it out. We could make this work. But if it’s for more than a year, it becomes difficult… I’m pretty tied to urban education. I am passionate about it. The chance of me being able to do what I do [in Trinidad] are nil.” Stacy states in a matter of fact tone.
When Karla leaves the country, she is required , to spend a year out of the United States before applying for a second work visa – a process that can take months and is pretty equivalent to a lottery system given the new limitations on the numbers admitted.
In practical terms, the best she can hope for is two and a half years outside the country before gaining permission to return to Chicago on a permanent basis.
“Pretty much our only hope is the United American Families Act passing.” Karla admits.
UAFA was introduced in the House and the Senate in February and is now slowly gathering support.
Stacy and Karla have started a letter writing campaign targeting all of their local representatives. They spoke to the office of brand new Congressman Mike Quigley (D-IL). And State Representative Deb Mell has agreed to sit down with them to discuss options. Karla spoke to an aide at Senator Dick Durbin’s (D-IL) office about her situation and they have written letters to Senator Roland Burris (D-IL), but neither Senator has signed on to co-sponsor the legislation.
Even Stacy’s sister, across the country in California, has begun a drive to get Congressional and Senate support for UAFA from her own representatives.
Most of this will not help Stacy and Karla.
Karla is applying to every job she can but admits that, as of right now, the Middle East is her best option. The pay is similar to that in the United States and Middle Eastern companies are some of the few actively hiring foreign workers. She already has an interview for a job in Kuwait.
Stacy grimaces when Karla starts to talk about moving so far away.
Sitting with Stacy and Karla, it is abundantly clear that these two women love each other very much.
In a few months, Karla will be forced to leave her partner, Kobi and her new puppy Maddi. Stacy will be left behind, only enjoying visits with Karla when she can travel overseas or Karla can acquire a visitor’s visa to return home for a short stay.
Stacy and Karla’s story is not unique, which only makes it harder to bear. No couple should be forced by government regulations to choose between their country, career and family and staying in the same place as the person they love.
One can only hope that quick passage of the UAFA will help people like Karla and Stacy have a fair shot at making a loving committed relationship work for the long term.



Been there, done that. I was in a 7 year relationship, that finally fell apart after not being able to be legal residents of each other’s country. By the time his country passed same sex couple immigration, it was to late. All the back and forth had taken it’s toll.
A seven year relationship without one fight, without once ever yelling at each other (the constant threat of not being able to be together helps in that department, I guess). Gone.
The stress finally did us in. That being said…, no one’s trying to hang me in the public square, but still… I don’t think that conservative hate people (did I say hate, I meant straight) realize what they are doing to their fellow human beings.
This is a great piece. Nice writing. I think bringing a few faces to this subject could really bring the need for actual change to the forefront. Great work. Couples are in this situation all to often with immigration.
Thank you so much for writing an article about this issue! We really need to increase awareness about UAFA and the painful choices same sex binational couples face. Now that we’ve seen how expressing our concerns to politicians can have an impact in places like Vermont, it’s time to push for UAFA! The more media attention we can get on this subject the better because people currently don’t seem to be aware of this issue! We need people to tell their stories, make youtube videos, and write to their representatives! We need people to donate to Immigration Equality , the organization currently doing the most to help UAFA pass! As for me, I’m in the UK with my partner where I can fortunately stay because they allow civil partnerships here that give me immigration rights. But it meant leaving a successful job in the US in a time of recession, taking a step back in my career, and being away from friends and family. No American should have to make the choice between staying with their partner and staying in their country!
@Lisa, I’m feeling the pain too. My partner is American and we have to count on either me getting a permanent work visa in autumn 2010 so I can join him in the US, or UAFA passing. At the moment, we are prepared to wait for another year or so but beyond that, if we want to stay together, he’s almost certainly going to have to move to Europe to be with me, either here in Britain, or we go to Spain together. I think at this stage, we have to try to get UAFA to a floor vote in the House. It’s with the Judiciary Committee yet and I keep saying to people that we have to get the support of those Democrats on the board who haven’t signed on yet.
- Dianne Feinstein (D-CA)
- Amy Klobuchar (D-MN)
- Richard Durban (D-IL)
- Herbert Kohl (D-WI)
- Edward Kaufman (D-DE)
The moderate Republican Arlen Specter could also be swayed, I imagine. Writing to John Kerry to ask him to keep the pressure on the Obama administration may also help. I’m sure Immigration Equality are considering what other bills they can attach UAFA to without much or any resistance from the Republicans; I’m not conviced that CIR is it.
@Lisa, I’m feeling the pain too. My partner is American and we have to count on either me getting a permanent work visa in autumn 2010 so I can join him in the US, or UAFA passing. At the moment, we are prepared to wait for another year or so but beyond that, if we want to stay together, he’s almost certainly going to have to move to Europe to be with me, either here in Britain, or we go to Spain together. I think at this stage, we have to try to get UAFA to a floor vote in the House. It’s with the Judiciary Committee yet and I keep saying to people that we have to get the support of those Democrats on the board who haven’t signed on yet.
- Dianne Feinstein (D-CA)
- Amy Klobuchar (D-MN)
- Richard Durban (D-IL)
- Herbert Kohl (D-WI)
- Edward Kaufman (D-DE)
The moderate Republican Arlen Specter could also be swayed, I imagine. Writing to John Kerry to ask him to keep the pressure on the Obama administration may also help. I’m sure Immigration Equality are considering what other bills they can attach UAFA to without much or any resistance from the Republicans; I’m not convinced that CIR is it.
we’re working on it too, UAFA is the hope of hopes, praying it passes soon for all of us
Truly our rights as gays in this country are unequal to straights if I can only sponsor someone for citizenship through marriage if I am of the opposite sex as my foreign partner. This should be upsetting for gays regardless of whether they have a foreign national for a partner or not. You never know when you might meet the love of your life, who happens to be a foreigner! It should be insulting to straights who think they live in a fair and just country. Support UAFA, or get that stupid, dumbass federal law DOMA repealed, asap! I realize that gays marrying locally in certain states is a big plus, but we are still not equal when it comes to federal laws. It’s not fair! There are tons of other countries more enlightened than us when it comes to this issue, and we are losing valuable citizens through migration! There are also about 36,000 same sex couples similar to the one featured here! Talk to your representatives about that!
We know what your going through, my partner of 4 years is a Trini and we have not been able to find a sponsor for H-B1 for her so we are reduced to only being able to visit each other over the last few years (and I can’t move there, as you know being gay is not quite the acceptable lifestyle in Trini). It’s hard, but we’re holding on. Be strong, and stay hopeful that UAFA passes for all of us.