November 22nd, 2009
 

365Gay Agenda Blog

Ruby-Sachs: Getting rid of the “fourth gender”

By Emma Ruby-Sachs, 365gay blogger 03.19.2009 8:53am EDT
Emirati women attend a football training session for Emirati schoolboys at the Football Club in the Gulf emirate of al-Ain on February 10, 2009.

Emirati women attend a football training session for Emirati schoolboys at the Football Club in the Gulf emirate of al-Ain on February 10, 2009.

Jezebel (one of my favorite sites) reported yesterday that the United Arab Emirates are pursuing a public awareness campaign about the infiltration of the fourth gender.

Many may remember the ongoing research on the “third gender,” a feminine man, physical man who’s gender identity does not match his sex, hermaphrodite or homosexual (depending on who you talk to).

I have seen reports about the notion of the third gender as a healthy inclusion of transgendered and homosexual individuals in societies otherwise intolerant of “deviant” sexual behavior. I have also read about the third sex as a pariah and low class of individuals tolerated, but not included.

That said, the UAE ministry of social affairs has launched a campaign called “Excuse me, I am a girl” aimed at ridding the “fourth gender” from the country. As Naji Hay (from the ministry) asserts:

“The phenomenon of manly women has become apparent in society…. These women are against the normal nature of females. Their deviant behavior threatens other normal girls. This is why we had to launch this initiative to protect society from this menace.”

What I found so fascinating about this report was its indication that gender performance is effectively equal to sexuality in the UAE. Manly women may be a threat because some are lesbians, but manly women are unacceptable even if they are not lesbians.

This element of performance runs throughout the research on the third gender and, frankly, throughout our own country’s understanding of LGBT people.

To what extent are we told to hide who we are, how we interact with people? How many times have you been yelled at or spit on while holding hands with your partner? More importantly, how many times have loved ones asked you to keep quiet and stop announcing “it” everywhere?

Even those most religious and intolerant Americans would be happy if gays and lesbians could acknowledge their deviance, overcome it and learn to behave in a normal way.

In some ways, the UAE has it right. The performance of new gender roles is threatening. It is the expression of difference and, sometimes, of a difference in attraction. This expression encourages diversity and communicates to others that they are not alone in their frustration with the roles they have been shown.

So here’s to manly women, in the UAE and at home. Proclaiming difference is never easy, and it is so vitally important.


Login or Register to comment.

or Login with Facebook:

  • Brandy Said: March 20th, 2009 at 1:14 am
    • Once again, the religious show how evil they really are.

  • Ben Said: March 19th, 2009 at 8:52 pm
    • It makes me sick to think of the increasing suffering our gay brothers and sisters in the Muslim world will inevitably endure as this century progresses.

      It should be one of our top priorities as a movement. Not sure how.

  • Eugene Said: March 19th, 2009 at 1:33 pm
    • @Fed Up: Tell me about it. I wonder how many people really understand what weltschmerz is.

  • Eugene Said: March 19th, 2009 at 1:31 pm
    • This sexism is why I willwrote to the Dubai authorities a few years ago telling them why I would never visit there. I will not give them my money to oppress women. Now, if only the civilised world make finding alternative sources of fuel the priority it should have been decades ago, that would really help a lot.

  • Bill S. Said: March 19th, 2009 at 11:51 am
    • “You know.. this is how camps and genocide starts.”

      I thought the same exact thing when I read this article.

  • chuck Said: March 19th, 2009 at 10:22 am
    • ‘rid the country’…

      You know.. this is how camps and genocide starts.

      Ugh.

  • TCS Said: March 19th, 2009 at 9:53 am
    • Once again, homophobia is intimately tangled with sexism and enforcement of a particular style of gender expression. That’s why we all need to be feminists and also work to protect everyone’s right to gender expression.

      On a lighter note, I wonder how a woman in head-to-toe covering manages to act butch. Sensible shoes? Extra pockets in the burqa?

  • Fed up Said: March 19th, 2009 at 9:26 am
    • I have decided this planet sucks…… how do I get off?

 
Login

Register
Lost your password?


or Login with Facebook