Withers: Angry black men don’t win elections
Here is something every minority has had to deal with: being compared to some fictional movie character. So if you are gay, at some point you had to tell a straight friend why you were not like the queen in the movie Mannequin. Once I had to go into deep boring detail on why my suburban upbringing did not make me a stand in for the characters in Boyz N The Hood.
Individual quirks matter little when you are a minority. Hold on. Let me rephrase that: those ticks of personality are very important (life saving I would argue but that is for another time) but in the broad stroke world of popular culture no one really cares.
Over at Salon, writer James Hannaham takes some media figures like Arianna Huffington to task for pushing the angry black man memo with Barack Obama. Some commentators find the Democratic nominee’s responses to GOP attacks too genteel. Instead they would like Obama to find his inner Denzel or Sidney and respond in high-drama cinematic action.
As Hannaham gently points out, asking Obama to be Morgan or Don is a bit strange considering how he is not them or better yet: Obama is not the characters those actors play on screen.
By looking to Obama to be Will, we are not paying attention to who the junior senator Illinois actually is. And to disregard the minority in front of you because he/she is not like the minority you are used to (or dream of), keeps us away from the day when we are imperfect individuals, not members of tribes that only describe us in part.



Angry black men may not win elections but passive black men NEVER win elections.
Many pundits say he is being to soft attacking McCain, while others say he is getting too angry. In the recent days, I have never thought of him as either. He is right where he needs to be. And him being an ‘angry black man’ never even crossed my mind; for, he is not black but bi-racial and he is not fuming with anger, but rather standing up for himself in a mature and honorable manner, when attacked with filthy slimy tactics.
Though people are justifyably angry at eight years of utter mismanagement and furious at the character assassination that passes for Republican campaigning, this is NO time to express it. It is time for everyone who wants a Democrat in the White House (and forming majorities in the House and Senate) to be at their wily best. Barack Obama, if elected, will have plenty of time for his Sidney/Will/Morgan/Don moment.
James I must disagree. It would be very refreshing to see a leader, black or otherwise, get angry as the state of our nation. After the last 8 years more than a few of us are pissed off and would love to see a little outrage from our potential leaders.